"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[madisong]

please help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85752361&userid=15467&signature=jNJzSScFIIfR19tAnEsewA

very unfair to you.
Just your TD BMD & Punk dog would be fair for the July PPS on their side.
And unfortunately, rats don’t trade for very much regardless of their rarity. I’ve personally only paid & traded my OMGSR rats at about a September list level, so the light leopard + some would be fair for it IMO.
edit;;
It’s been brought to my attention my eyes missed the poor baby squid at the end, my bad haha.
I’d still find it unfair just as I personally trade with quantity values in mind. Especially with lower list and store pet quantity, I don’t think it would be enough. I’d value your side a lot higher just due to the quantity. If needed, I might be able to provide some old trades I have with quantity involved.

[angst]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85769658&userid=296382&signature=qFTec26J4IOIksuQu-kp6w

really not sure what to offer for these store pets except WL older rares; I thought I was overpaying but they claimed this was unfair to them. been out of the trading scene for years, is this unfair now? have the value of store pets somehow skyrocketed? thank you!

[~SNCastiel<3~]

Never mind~

[Smaug The Dragon]

This, demand wise? Should I see if they can change the October pup?
This too. Demand wise. What should be taken off my side to just get the PPS? I don't want to overtrade.
And another please.
And this. I am willing to o erpay slightly for them.
Been asking for a few days.
Please help.

[phoenix <3]

Please help I've been asking for ages

[re4]

would this be a fair bid?

would this be fair as well?

[GhostFaceッ]

ur malk dog = ur pps galaxy cat?

[rea;]

Would this be fair demand and rarity wise? Thanks, sorry I don't know much ^^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85769874&userid=815675&signature=IX3t1SaC6jh1oNh1iFjy2A
Thank you!

[Vaal Hazak]

is this fair?
if not, what would be needed for addition?
thank you

[Camden]

How’s this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85769882&userid=889724&signature=sziN3jI1n_ldql-vLmiIdw