"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764330&userid=753157&signature=rH6n8Q4x7-8UuDq2aNxy7Q
How fair do you think this is due to how much people like the baby cheetah ?

I traded for mine yesterday and it was a lottttt less :https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85742209&userid=659538&signature=HNtwu6p87vGyCzJMj-5PxA

I would accept

Im unable to view the trade above, but does anyone else have an opinion?
{my trade link again} trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764330&userid=753157&signature=rH6n8Q4x7-8UuDq2aNxy7Q

Rarity wise they're overpaying by a fair bit (~1-1.5 '09 rares, in fact) and since that's a sitting cat you might well be able to get a little overpay for it if you're not planning on keeping it. I'd definitely take it.

[Luxio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85761159&userid=672119&signature=F8xK_-jZi5-fbpYVzWv-Wg
Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

[Mellø]

hi! would this be fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764494&userid=956683&signature=rke2P8fyM3qA5-o-XMC1Kg
and, if i were able to get a BA or a dark leopard dog, how many nons would it be worth if it is worth anything?

[x.mech.x]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764523&userid=654909&signature=QjCA9iK2J82jXTHtcUMKpg can someone assist me with this? I'm not sure if I'm overpaying or not

[wrath of man.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764523&userid=654909&signature=QjCA9iK2J82jXTHtcUMKpg can someone assist me with this? I'm not sure if I'm overpaying or not

No, infact they're overpaying. The ur bee usually goes for 2-2.5 nons whereas the ceg goes for 1.5 so theire side i 2.5

[MysticalDragonDog]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764286&userid=844234&signature=NhNJ_vpmgXFRrYAT85XRfQ
The Rudolph dog is from Christmasn2010

Would this be considered fair? I personally like my dragon more but like if the dog has good demand would it be worth taking? Idk what to do oof.

???

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764286&userid=844234&signature=NhNJ_vpmgXFRrYAT85XRfQ
The Rudolph dog is from Christmasn2010

Would this be considered fair? I personally like my dragon more but like if the dog has good demand would it be worth taking? Idk what to do oof.

???

no. speaking from personal experience, the dress is a nightmare to trade for and at the very least is worth an '11 uncommon. imo, it's worth an '11 rare, but that's open to discussion. the tunic is less hunted for and much more common, so you're looking more along the lines of a c/uc for that.
the dragon is worth a mid '10 rare, so with an '11 uc or two on top you're looking at roughly an early '10's worth on your side. imo you could possibly push that to a late '09 with the dress and the decent demand for store pets.
by the 2;1 rule they're underpaying, since their side is only worth a late '10 rare and a couple of '10 OMGSCs.
if you don't care too much about dates, this is arguably fair, but i really wouldn't take it personally.

[Smaug The Dragon]

This, demand wise? Should I see if they can change the October pup?
This too. Demand wise. What should be taken off my side to just get the PPS? I don't want to overtrade.
And another please.
And this. I am willing to overpay slightly for them.
Been asking for a few days.
Please help.

[Bellarke]

Looking for a second opinion on this if possible. What would be fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=85662927&userid=826935&signature=28dvsH2RSXCIPq-T_kXgow

[pluvio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764692&userid=980494&signature=i7s2TEdPVHkV5LkS_ac64g

An opinions are welcome!