"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[StarsNeedDarkness]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85763711&userid=980587&signature=E1u9ohDNG5AFicBqJcTNaQ

[Guest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85737974&userid=659538&signature=9CEOP0T4o_kLPKZ9LJOxzA

Is the brown sliepnir for the joker fair?? The sleipnir is a store pet and has really good demand so idk help my soul

Unfair to you. The Brown Sleipnir is going for 3 Nons+ while the Joker goes for around 1 - 1.5 Nons.

Brown sleipnir is 2 nons at most, not 3

[Vaal Hazak]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85737974&userid=659538&signature=9CEOP0T4o_kLPKZ9LJOxzA

Is the brown sliepnir for the joker fair?? The sleipnir is a store pet and has really good demand so idk help my soul

Unfair to you. The Brown Sleipnir is going for 3 Nons+ while the Joker goes for around 1 - 1.5 Nons.

Brown sleipnir is 2 nons at most, not 3

Shame on me, I misread something. Anyways, the trade is still unfair to the Sleipnir.
Personally I wouldn't trade a Sleipnir for a Joker, just because of the fact that the Joker is re-released and the Sleipnir won't.

[wet rat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85762813&userid=919651&signature=nkglywQvBGFbfZpBcwOwTQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85763016&userid=919651&signature=8e4J-5IlRhKj5mq767VFww

Are either of these fair?

[D E L I R I U M]

ok now i really dont know

[FOUND VERDICT]

If I could get some opinions on these 2 trades for my skelebun I'd appreciate it.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85754456&userid=521518&signature=pllC_C1TMHdhgc_NISh5Vg + off site currency that's value is about that of a Brown Sleipnir
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85750548&userid=521518&signature=mLvdtZKAYoniOMceIlPYXA
Even if your not sure on which is worth more go by which you prefer and why please - thank you!

that's tricky, both are really nice...
personally, the second looks more appealing considering the orange cerb (7+ nons) and quantity.

demand for the tigers seems to have died down a bit, i've seen them going for around 5-6 nons lately which is a lot less then it used be. the raven, patchie, ur holly, ur lion and malk are all in the 1-2 nons range.

going by how i value pets, the second offer would also be better in value.

[Vaal Hazak]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85762813&userid=919651&signature=nkglywQvBGFbfZpBcwOwTQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85763016&userid=919651&signature=8e4J-5IlRhKj5mq767VFww

Are either of these fair?

First trade: Unfair to them as your side is only worth a late 2009 rare and a late 2010 rare.
Second trade: Looks unfair to them, as the quantity of the draft horses doesn't fetch the two uncommons. The VRs for each other are fair.

//

[Niragi]

ok now i really dont know

The scarf by itself is worth a ‘08 R/VR so they’re overpaying by quite a bit. It’s up to you how to value item demand but I’ve never had trouble getting the full worth for the old ‘08/‘09 items, so I’d personally prefer the item side as I haven’t seen the bunny having any special demand.

[StarsNeedDarkness]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85763711&userid=980587&signature=E1u9ohDNG5AFicBqJcTNaQ

[AustrianAce]

What is the UR mint Tess horse typically valued at?
I know the tess horses have relatively low demand