"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[FOUND VERDICT]

How’s this looking? Is it worth it?

i personally would stick with the ur cake.
the demand for the squid seems to have died down a bit, i've seen it going closer to an non lately whereas cake trades for 1.5 nons

[~Ney & Mid~]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85622140&userid=225421&signature=zwVA18eQHtQKsfbE0kvl0Q

Fair?(:

[Dalmatian]

Been asking for quite a while now, any help is greatly appreciated ^^

Need a lil help, what do both of the horses usually go for? Would it be fair demand/rarity wise? Any help is greatly appreciated! ^^

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85616469&userid=871576&signature=HHkRYNOwdfEiApw4lyV62Q

rarity wise I would say this is a fair offer but demand wise I see the horse on the bottom go for a bit more. and since nick horses aren't all that high demand, i'd say you could get better. get a second opinion tho!

Thank you! Any second opinions?

[Troopercat]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85620289&userid=944060&signature=vcOO4zZgy3Ntrhe_GgCx_A

I'm not sure if this is fair..

[FenrirtheKBD]

How fair was this? I feel like I overpaid, but honestly it’s fine. I love the Tess cat, people seem to like it demand wise as well.
Please PM me the answer! Thank you in advance.

Second opinion?? Thank you

[.Aurora.]

Hi! I’m having trouble deciding if this would be worth it for the ur tea cup/avocado

[plecostomus enjoyer]

is this fair? i have no idea what my squiddy is worth trade wise
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85619914&userid=899506&signature=x6zeg4bZwqaIZy6wKqMhig
what would make it fair if it isnt?

[gaster.r]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85618269&userid=927777&signature=EKy2gj0fIXD5QWkWTFeBNw

Is this fair on my side? Thanks in advance c:

[Dalmatian]

Need a lil help, what do both of the horses usually go for? Would it be fair demand/rarity wise? Any help is greatly appreciated! ^^

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85616469&userid=871576&signature=HHkRYNOwdfEiApw4lyV62Q

any second opinions on this?

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

Hey there fair trade helpers, I'm back with a few bids for my orange cerberus I'd like to get some opinions on!

This one is Bid #13 consisting of some great lists and 3 old store pets. I'm expecting the green liontail to go OMG so Rare in January too, and I know that typically spikes demand up with that.

Then my other favorite offer is Bid #7 with a few lower tier store pets but the red cerb has better demand than the liontails if I remember correctly.

Another offer I have is Bid #11 which has a drink me (those going for 4 nons right now?) and a lot of C$. I know the C$ adds up to somewhere past 7 nons alone according to the C$ trade thread, but I also know there aren't a lot of people who sell high list pets for C$ directly so it does make me a bit nervous to put this bid in the lead.

I was wondering if I could please get a few opinions about what you feel the total value in nons would be of all the offers, with demand factored in? Thanks so much for any help!!!