[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[asphodelian]

Is this a fair trade?
(Just as contexts I really love lions and foxes so...)

That's not even remotely close to fair to you. Your pet is a '10 rerelease.

100% agreed

Thanks, guys!

[Mellø]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85101835&userid=956683&signature=DIVTjKZ35-P-NNUu7NSfpQ
is this fair?

[mushroomish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85101947&userid=978329&signature=CzBq7tjIzrVSKfqvcl8mFg

how's this? thank u in advance!

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

I need some opinions on the following trades please and thank you!!

Trade #1
Trade #2
Trade #3
Trade #4

Thank you so much to anyone who helps me out!!

[polyphon]

are these trades fair? thanks for any help <3
trade 1
trade 2

[Hana Song]

Unsure about this trade since the store pets are BRAND NEW O:

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85101947&userid=978329&signature=CzBq7tjIzrVSKfqvcl8mFg

how's this? thank u in advance!

It's a low advent list pet, so no, this isn't even close to fair. It's worth 3-4 mixed 2009 rares; the pets they're offering are too new to make up the difference.

are these trades fair? thanks for any help <3
trade 1
trade 2

Both are unfair to you. They'd need the equivalent of 4 2009 rares per card dog.

Unsure about this trade since the store pets are BRAND NEW O:

Unfair to you. 2019 store pets are valued as late 2010 rares each, at the very least. With the end of the year coming that may change, but it would be change in favor of the store pets, not the regular rares.

[Scaledowl]

Is this fair?
Click to view trade

[SeaCrest]

Is this fair?
Click to view trade

Unfair to the top by a little under 2.5 2018 uncommons!

[koalaplushie]

Im really conflicted about this trade and I need help haha. So the green Alien dog is a dreamie of mine but I'd really like to trade my Angry basilisk for a Shy Basilisk so idk. I would like to know if rarity wise this trade is fair! trades/viewtrade.php?id=85102895&userid=674298&signature=vXzREWd-OLN8UQzJwVnQUA