[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[sagittarius.]

Is this a fair trade? thanks in advance <3

[boston]

Some opinions please?
Unsure what to think as the store pet won’t be released again.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450327&userid=641753&signature=mIIxQDzJwkwxx1hyBU9Zdg

[Gabyslá]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450329&userid=938569&signature=nmVBgzL1aUcTw6QGfr1msg

Would you take this?

[Niragi]

I would like some help with this trade please: link

I wouldn't! The holly dog only tends to go for a non sometimes a non and a half whereas the dog tag is worth a lot more!

Would like a second opinion! If they added a BEG on their side, would it make a difference?

I personally value both the UR Holly and the Dogtag at 1.5 nons due to demand, so I’d say it’s a fair trade. It all comes down to how you value your pet though, but I’ve personally not seen a dogtag going for 2+ Nons in the past few months, therefore in my opinion adding a BEG, which can get 1-1.5 nons, to the other side would be overkill.
If anything I’d ask them to add around sorbet worth as the dogtag usually sits at 2 nons worth~

[snowdrake]

Is this a fair trade? thanks in advance <3

no. a 2015 uncommon is worth 32 2019 commons c:

[Asvoria]

I would like some help with this trade please: link

I wouldn't! The holly dog only tends to go for a non sometimes a non and a half whereas the dog tag is worth a lot more!

Would like a second opinion! If they added a BEG on their side, would it make a difference?

Yeah that'd make it much more fair. Holly dog is 1-1.5 nons (closer to 1 non at the moment though) and BEG is 1-1.5 nons, so 2-3 nons overall, and the dogtag goes for at least 2, but up to 3 nons (although its demand has dipped recently). So it depends on what you and your trading partner value the holly & BEG at, but if around 2-2.5 nons then fair

I personally value both the UR Holly and the Dogtag at 1.5 nons due to demand, so I’d say it’s a fair trade. It all comes down to how you value your pet though, but I’ve personally not seen a dogtag going for 2+ Nons in the past few months, therefore in my opinion adding a BEG to the other side would be overkill.
If anything I’d ask them to add around sorbet worth as the dogtag usually sits at 2 nons worth~

Thank you very much for your answers! Let's see if we'll be able to settle somewhere in the middle

[cαtαstrσphe]

Yeah that'd make it much more fair. Holly dog is 1-1.5 nons (closer to 1 non at the moment though) and BEG is 1-1.5 nons, so 2-3 nons overall, and the dogtag goes for at least 2, but up to 3 nons (although its demand has dipped recently). So it depends on what you and your trading partner value the holly & BEG at, but if around 2-2.5 nons then fair :)

Dog tag has been at 1.5 nons for months, I'd like to see this 2.5-3 nons proof please 👀

[dippy.]

hey i was wondering if this : trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450347&userid=592006&signature=K1gFNKsYhaClm-x44bTHTA is a fair trade? i know zodiacs are high demand but idk about the other pets! please help!

[Sugar Boy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85449553&userid=591055&signature=GI-SiGGWG_eAr2NpR44iqg

What do you guys think about this?

technically they are overpaying slightly because your store pet is worth a late 09 rare. however, store pets have pretty crazy demand right now and I believe you can get more for your horse. don't get me wrong, it's not a bad offer, but personally I would wait for something else!

I really need some help, is this fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85449930&userid=651521&signature=NnHLeGVgMDbrLovL19H4gw

Thanks!!!!!

your side is worth a little more than 6 09 rares, so it's a pretty decent offer for the zodiacs. I usually traded mine for 1.5-3 09 rares (depending on how their demand was at that particular time).

Thank you for your advice and input!

[luckydiime]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85447331&userid=977024&signature=SDmwKfMe_-u2mO5xwUKJJA

is this a fair trade?? sorry if this is a stupid question!!