[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[PINKPink!]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85363347&userid=606909&signature=MsJjdYs-TxGNY-Ti8OOe_w

Thank you to the lovely person who answered! I would still like another opinion just to be sure though! Thank you again to anyone who answers^^

[delani]

would love any thoughts on this offer?

I am unsure what the phoenix goes for and where a full set of the '11 store horses would be generally valued

[Rhiley]

I'm bad at item trades! Anyone have any thoughts?

[maisie+flokez]

this?
i’m really bad with big rare trades so any advice would be fantastic <3

I'm also pretty bad at OMGSR trades but I feel pretty comfortable saying that this is unfair to you. Rats are hard to trade off, even OMGSR ones, and the foal is quite popular.

The UR foal can get 1.5 nons, whereas the rats, although they're valued at around a non are barely trading for a sorbet, I've never seen one go for higher (other than the UR rat, which is valued much higher). So unfair to you.

[cubone.]

this?
i’m really bad with big rare trades so any advice would be fantastic <3

I'm also pretty bad at OMGSR trades but I feel pretty comfortable saying that this is unfair to you. Rats are hard to trade off, even OMGSR ones, and the foal is quite popular.

The UR foal can get 1.5 nons, whereas the rats, although they're valued at around a non are barely trading for a sorbet, I've never seen one go for higher. So unfair to you.

^ I’ve never even managed to get anywhere near a sorbet for the rats because they’re so hard to trade off Even without awful demand the foal still goes for more!

[XxDragonScalesxX]

I'm bad at item trades! Anyone have any thoughts?

The stands are from 2011 and worth an 2011 uncommon each and the backgrounds/plant stuff is from 2013 which are worth an uncommon from 2013 each. You might be able to get a rare for the mountains but that really depends on your trade partner. So in total, your side would be worth around 36-46C$ or 42-54C$ valuing the mountain at a rare.

[smartiez]

what needs to happen on their side?

[cubone.]

what needs to happen on their side?

The Fox is from valentines 2010 - so another early 2010 rare pet (and remove the uc). or a 2011 rare + another 2011 uc, or 3 more 2011 UCs. (If you use the 2:1 rule)

[Kittytalia]

Need help urgently- TD sorb for Clockwork??

[Spine]

Need help urgently- TD sorb for Clockwork??

i'd go for the clockwork over the punk, since the clockwork bun goes for about a non as where the punk goes for a sorb