[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[MusicalMaladies]

I'm so bad at balancing trades. Is this trade fair for both sides?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85311043&userid=801693&signature=DV45IGh1m8bDoJ3UTiStTw

[Jawy.EXE]

I'm so bad at balancing trades. Is this trade fair for both sides?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85311043&userid=801693&signature=DV45IGh1m8bDoJ3UTiStTw

Very unfair for you

[infinitestarsx]

I'm so bad at balancing trades. Is this trade fair for both sides?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85311043&userid=801693&signature=DV45IGh1m8bDoJ3UTiStTw

Very unfair for you

its actually very unfair for the other person. the person who posted this trade is offering a regular 2009 very rare and the other side is offering multiple 2011 rares. 2:1 ratio. 2 rares make one rare from the year before.

[Ironic Equation]

Should I accept this for my Raven?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85329137&userid=830519&signature=CPwyBr0dCp9c6hOBE6EY3g

personally i see the bee go for around 2.5 nons. the raven on your side is 2 nons, the C$ is a bit under a sorb, and the other pets are nice adds although they don't change much about the final value. i would say you're a bit under

Honestly I see the bee and raven as a straight swap demand wise, and wouldn't add to the raven. When I had one for trade it was always valued at 2 nons and I even got an offer I'd value at 2.5 nons. I generally see the bee get 2 nons.

[rosé]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85316155&userid=952073&signature=Rz0y3dJniiXLVdaRyFlu9A
should i accept this? thanks for any help!

I'd say unfair to them. I've paid 2 nons worth for TD BEG/CEGs in the past and yes their demand has dropped a little but you should very easily get 1.5 nons worth each, more with patience. Valuing their side at the very least 3 nons, imo it's overpay as the sleipnir seems to go for about 2.5 nons now ^^

thank you! could i get a second opinion?

[Vampyrean]

Is this a fair trade for a yellow toxic?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85330124&userid=649378&signature=5WLQge4YDvc7yPz_vEWycQ

I'm pretty sure I've made it fair for them, but I want to make sure before I accept!

[cαtαstrσphe]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85316155&userid=952073&signature=Rz0y3dJniiXLVdaRyFlu9A
should i accept this? thanks for any help!

I'd say unfair to them. I've paid 2 nons worth for TD BEG/CEGs in the past and yes their demand has dropped a little but you should very easily get 1.5 nons worth each, more with patience. Valuing their side at the very least 3 nons, imo it's overpay as the sleipnir seems to go for about 2.5 nons now ^^

thank you! could i get a second opinion?

Agreed, they're definitely over in value, it's a good trade.

[MusicalMaladies]

I'm so bad at balancing trades. Is this trade fair for both sides?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85311043&userid=801693&signature=DV45IGh1m8bDoJ3UTiStTw

Very unfair for you

Thanks for the input!

[*the dark one]

Hey is this a fair trade and how much is my apple rally worth ?? trades/viewtrade.php?id=85324892&userid=558093&signature=GiWVL2Y7xoNG2i8W8P6YuA

[infinitestarsx]

Hey is this a fair trade and how much is my apple rally worth ?? trades/viewtrade.php?id=85324892&userid=558093&signature=GiWVL2Y7xoNG2i8W8P6YuA

IM prtty sure they are over by a lot. spotted tribal is worht 2 sorbs and the apple isnt even worth half of 1

i dont think it has special demand either.. in fact its bad demand

someone correct me if im wrong but im pretty sure im correct