[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[c r i m i n a l.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85233935&userid=937999&signature=wVXFUOrFOy1CWzz0DZRBmw

Would appreciate advice ASAP, is this relatively fair or should I change the rare they've offered to something else?

EDIT: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85234080&userid=937999&signature=UbXQ56s4lyfCDwjwFZDB0Q
Is this fair for my '15 SP?? If not what should be added or changed? I'm really rusty with store pet value

[Spine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85233935&userid=937999&signature=wVXFUOrFOy1CWzz0DZRBmw

Would appreciate advice ASAP, is this relatively fair or should I change the rare they've offered to something else?

personally i wouldn't take it. people are saying when this year ends 2017 store pets will be going up in value, and will be worth a late 2009 rare

[mak.]

help!!
i know the holly dog has good demand and it's kind of hard to get, but should i do this? i really want to,, i'm just very conflicted. any advice is greatly appreciated

any other opinions please?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85233935&userid=937999&signature=wVXFUOrFOy1CWzz0DZRBmw

Would appreciate advice ASAP, is this relatively fair or should I change the rare they've offered to something else?

slightly unfair to you, since the '17 sp goes for an early '10 rare and in january will be worth a late '09. i'd see if you can push that up to a pet from december '09/january '10 personally.

[vina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85222299&userid=981321&signature=KR96wNO2cpt7n9bvcteclw

i can't tell if this is just out of niceness, they seem like they're well aware of the trade being possibly overpay but i'm bad with trading vr+ pets \: just need an opinion from someone who knows whats up, thank you.

[chiamia]

not sure about this item trade

[powpowx]

Hello! How fair is this for my corgi set? <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85234094&userid=943796&signature=8FEoTGoucCmfFB9LeVcyaw

[honeycreeper]

how does this trade look? what's the demand on the butterbun? thank you for any help!

honey

Well we can throw demand out the window in the corner
This isn’t really fair to the butterbun at all. If we value it at a non then they’re way over
Even If we offer it at a sorb they’re still over ;0; as far as I know the bun isnt going for a toxic. I’d ask them about it? Make sure they know what they’re doing

thank you! may I have another opinion?

[mushroomish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85222233&userid=978329&signature=_Tc1qnjwSOJI6AwXje5m0Q

how's this? i'm not sure on the worth of the butterfly wolf. i know it's a list but i forget what it goes for

pls can i get an answer i've been asking for several pages! thank u

[.Elysian.]

how does this trade look? what's the demand on the butterbun? thank you for any help!

honey

Well we can throw demand out the window in the corner
This isn’t really fair to the butterbun at all. If we value it at a non then they’re way over
Even If we offer it at a sorb they’re still over ;0; as far as I know the bun isnt going for a toxic. I’d ask them about it? Make sure they know what they’re doing

thank you! may I have another opinion?

i agree with the other person. the butterbun reaches a non [possibly less if the demand isn't as great] however i believe red toxic doesn't have a great demand... but either way, the other person is over