[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85133137&userid=326115&signature=j-xOl0sx2Bvrd0yDFUI_yw

would you consider this a fair trade? thank you in advance for the advice

the koi is from March 2010. As a VR it's worth 2 2010 rares. Your warrior was available until August 2010, making it worth a 2010 rare. This is overpay, even considering demand for warrior cats.

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

Need some opinions on this trade please!

[Rinla]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85132897&userid=326115&signature=9Lxeu6VxjlCg4xiGYn_chg

Is this fair? Thank you

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85132897&userid=326115&signature=9Lxeu6VxjlCg4xiGYn_chg

Is this fair? Thank you

No, they'd need to add another 2010 rare.

[chiamia]

hi, I'm looking for some opinions on this offer. would you take it ?

[xSav]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85143608&userid=878859&signature=CHjqEI9CzWPE7W5Ol_pegQ
Fair?

[maisie+flokez]

Can someone help with this please?

Thanks in advance!

EDIT: Also, is this fair rarity and demand-wise?

How about this?

[Nira.]

Any thoughts on this offer, please? c:
Both rarity and demand wise - is it fair/unfair and if unfair, what shall be changed?
Thank you in advance ♥

[Katskatskats]

Is this fair? Im a bit unsure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85144481&userid=825453&signature=GBkoDjMo3wSN2bPiwSH4bg

[cαtαstrσphe]

Is this fair? Im a bit unsure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85144481&userid=825453&signature=GBkoDjMo3wSN2bPiwSH4bg

By rarity it is unfair to them, however zodiacs commonly trade for 2x 09 rares/1 2009 very rare or 150C$.

Any thoughts on this offer, please? c:
Both rarity and demand wise - is it fair/unfair and if unfair, what shall be changed?
Thank you in advance ♥

A tricky one.. your side is valued at 3.5-4.5 nons (1.5-2 for the coontail and 2-2.5 for the dog tag), their side is valued at 3 nons or more. Raven trades for 3 nons, the bulk of stores.. hmm.. personally I value 5 2011s are a sorbet, except the basilisks that trade for a low main-sorbet for the set (RARELY).. so it's not a bad offer, however, some people are put of by the coontail and dog tag because they're "not in high demand".

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85143608&userid=878859&signature=CHjqEI9CzWPE7W5Ol_pegQ
Fair?

2017 store pet is worth about an early 2010 rare, the PPS is rare because it is so popular and thus really common. So it seems silly to trade it for a 2009 rare.

hi, I'm looking for some opinions on this offer. would you take it ?

Cursed PPS Dragon Cat trade for anything between a low advent to a low main, maybe a sorbet (VERY RARELY), their side is worth a high September list so not a bad offer imo.