The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[floor.]

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help

Also, for this, i'm not a huge fan of the pets they offered other than the stone dog and the warrior, but is it worth to accept it based on the sitting cat being offered?

[Sali]

Can someone help me with this trade I sent? Is it fair for both sides? c:

Trade

[cαtαstrσphe]

Can someone help me with this trade I sent? Is it fair for both sides? c:

Trade

Store scarves can go for anything between an advent list and a low main, some are more common and others more rare, I believe the black one is one of the harder ones. I've not idea how to rate this trade though, items are not my forte.

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help :)

Also, for this, i'm not a huge fan of the pets they offered other than the stone dog and the warrior, but is it worth to accept it based on the sitting cat being offered?

Already answered the first one.
The second one.. is tricky. Those horses are valued at a mid-September list or near that atm, maybe higher or lower depending on who you're trading with. I've had a hard time finding these and, given that they are almost as rare (if not rarer) than the raven dog, I'd not do this trade.

is this trade fair?
ty for any help c:

alas what is that mysterious pet
The skelebun, ever mysterious and ever harder to find, trades for 10+ nons easy, 12, 14, maybe more depending on how pets are valued and what's in the trade. Your side is worth about 11+ nons, if it were me I'd have taken this, skelebuns do not come around often. This is how I valued your pets, those these values are subjected to vary among users.
moonswirl 3 nons
liontail 3 nons
Non-coon, GWJ, CEG, BA 1 non each
BMD 1 sorbet - 1 non
Holy fox high advent

Is this fair??? It's a bid for 500C$
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84940642&userid=838891&signature=ou8qscCzyEFKq4i2ZkbDJg

Using the guide, their side is worth about 400-440 C$. BUT you can also trade for a green toxic - sorbet tier mainlist for 500C$, so it's up to you. I traded a wood winged angel for 500C$ for example, so it can be done.
2009 rare/very rare = 40-45+ C$ (x7)
2008 very rare = 55+ C$ (x2)
2011 rare = 10-15+ C$

[floor.]

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help

Also, for this, i'm not a huge fan of the pets they offered other than the stone dog and the warrior, but is it worth to accept it based on the sitting cat being offered?

Already answered the first one.
The second one.. is tricky. Those horses are valued at a mid-September list or near that atm, maybe higher or lower depending on who you're trading with. I've had a hard time finding these and, given that they are almost as rare (if not rarer) than the raven dog, I'd not do this trade.

Ah, so sorry, I completely missed your reply to my first question - thank you And wow, I didn't know the carousel horses were that hard to come by. Thank you once again for your help

[BraveEguana]

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help

Also, for this, i'm not a huge fan of the pets they offered other than the stone dog and the warrior, but is it worth to accept it based on the sitting cat being offered?

A Zodiac, from what I know, goes for 2 '09 rares nowadays, so I'd accept it, especially since it's a re-release.

[Griffin Torrens]

My Raven Dog for a Strawberry and Rainbow mane(?)?
Thank you for the help! I know store pets have been very popular lately and an warey of trading him away...

[cαtαstrσphe]

My Raven Dog for a Strawberry and Rainbow mane(?)?
Thank you for the help! I know store pets have been very popular lately and an warey of trading him away...

The raven trades for about 2 nons, the RBM 1 non and the strawberry 1.5 nons (more or less). So they're overpaying in both senses of the word.

[silvertogold]

Is this trade fair?
xxx
thank you in advance ♥

[Login [ Logout ] Log]

click
umm, help?
thanks.

[phxyvi]

is this trade fair?
ty for any help c:

There’s about 9 nons in your side, skelebun goes from 8-10 (usually laying in the higher side)

I would take it without hesitation, tbh
When else are ya gonna get a skelebun, they aren’t easy to come by and this is a great offer