The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunfloweer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84948418&userid=956725&signature=mo0ceNRUO2CQz065DSlQ-A

) not sure if this is fair?

anyone?

[ThunderCedar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84948418&userid=956725&signature=mo0ceNRUO2CQz065DSlQ-A

) not sure if this is fair?

anyone?

The 1 balloon on their side is overpay. All these items are from the same event and are worth the same.

[silvertogold]

Is this trade fair?
xxx
thank you in advance ♥

[floor.]

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help

Also, for this, i'm not a huge fan of the pets they offered other than the stone dog and the warrior, but is it worth to accept it based on the sitting cat being offered?

[cαtαstrσphe]

Not too sure what zodiacs are going for nowadays, would you take this? I'm not super keen as I only have one of that zodiac but if it's a good offer I will reconsider ^^ Thanks for any help :)

Zodiacs trade for about two 2009 rares that I've seen, so this is about fair as their very rare is from October 2009.

Thoughts about this bid for my orange cerb? I quite like it, but I'm concerned the gap between red and orange cerb will increase greatly and the lists in this won't quite fill the gap.

[Griffin Torrens]

My Raven Dog for a Strawberry and Rainbow mane(?)?
Thank you for the help! I know store pets have been very popular lately and an warey of trading him away...

[sweetmosso'mine]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84949108&userid=827270&signature=EgX8mWS5eAgD5s1yyF4jXg
This doesn't seem fair for them? They suggested this and want me to edit. The old rares they offer aren't on my wishlist but they're still really old rares... how do I value the pets they offer vs mine?
There is a lot of information to sort through here so some help would be appreciated.

[Griffin Torrens]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84949108&userid=827270&signature=EgX8mWS5eAgD5s1yyF4jXg
This doesn't seem fair for them? They suggested this and want me to edit. The old rares they offer aren't on my wishlist but they're still really old rares... how do I value the pets they offer vs mine?
There is a lot of information to sort through here so some help would be appreciated.

Most people value rares at a 2:1 date ratio. Meaning two of your 2019 rares = one 2018 rare.

Using this, if I did my maths correctly.. your side is roughly only worth a 2015 rare? So yes, it's rather unfair for them. (I'd check the maths yourself though haha)

[INDIG0]

Is this fair??? It's a bid for 500C$
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84940642&userid=838891&signature=ou8qscCzyEFKq4i2ZkbDJg

[kuzya]

is this trade fair?
ty for any help c: