The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Daisukina]

[HUGE amount of pets warning]
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84157226&userid=948983&signature=tXcgpV5zGqRnZX5hfpC-UQ ?

[♥Sterek♥]

[HUGE amount of pets warning]
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84157226&userid=948983&signature=tXcgpV5zGqRnZX5hfpC-UQ ?

This trade is very unfair to the top. If I looked correctly there is only 4 normal rares on your side and some quantity but nowhere near close the worth of the coontail.

[Blue_Aussie]

[HUGE amount of pets warning]
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84157226&userid=948983&signature=tXcgpV5zGqRnZX5hfpC-UQ ?

This trade is very unfair to the top. If I looked correctly there is only 4 normal rares on your side and some quantity but nowhere near close the worth of the coontail.

agreed. I would never accept if I were them.

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I accept this?

What about this?

[inulmori]

• bid #1: 9/10, i really like it!

• bid #2: cancelled

• bid #3: 8/10, it is pretty fair

• bid #4: 9/10, i like this too!

• bid #5: tbd, asking the fair trade tread

• bid #6: tbd, asking the fair trade thread

• bid #7: tbd!

• bid #8: tbd!

help?

[KenmilltoSky]

Would this be fair? Thank you!

[ThunderCedar]

Would this be fair? Thank you!

As an item collector, I can safely tell you I would not accept this. The elf set pieces are easily going for a 2010 rare each. In that case, just the elf pieces on your side can get you at least 5 2010 rares. Their side only adds up to 3.

[signal]

URGENT!!! PLEASE I GOTTA KNOW trades/viewtrade.php?id=84232324&userid=966857&signature=n-tKwU0opu6WHSd-ZF6_ag

[Blue_Aussie]

URGENT!!! PLEASE I GOTTA KNOW trades/viewtrade.php?id=84232324&userid=966857&signature=n-tKwU0opu6WHSd-ZF6_ag

They are overpaying by a lot! Its only gonna be a 2019 rare at most.

[amarok.]

URGENT!!! PLEASE I GOTTA KNOW trades/viewtrade.php?id=84232324&userid=966857&signature=n-tKwU0opu6WHSd-ZF6_ag

Daft overpay. That pet is most likely going to turn out to be either uncommon or, unlikely, a rare. Any pet from '11 would work out to be overpay in the grand scheme of things following 2:1 date maths. You're making it out like a bandit with this offer.