The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ketz]

I need some help, thanks to anyone who can provide input :3 Trade

my math may be off, so feel free to get a second opinion, but this seems pretty unfair to them. assuming the lion and dog from this event will both be rares, your side only adds up to 1 2015 rare, so just one of their unicorns would technically be fair rarity wise. its a good offer to you, but they're overpaying by more than double what your side is worth.

[kitsuwn]

Is this a fair trade for my Red Malk Dragon?

Please? qwq

[ketz]

Is this a fair trade for my Red Malk Dragon?

Please? qwq

This is definitely unfair to you. Most people wouldn't trade such a high demand list pet for random off-list pets anyway, but even if youre looking for a quantity trade down, this is still unfair to you rarity wise. IIRC, tier 1 september lists are worth around 25 '09 rares, but their side only adds up to around 16 and some misc from the newer commons/uncommons (even including the value of store pets & re-releases-- i'd value this at maybe 20 '09 rares total because of the demand for the pps fox, but not much more than that). This isn't even including the value of demand, and red malk dragons tend to go for quite a bit more than that anyway. You could get a better offer pretty easily.

[mazel1999]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84180960&userid=90447&signature=zkm-6uEJeVH-9yhL4-u_vg

Hello, is this a fair trade?

Still waiting on an answer ^.^

[Vanhishikha]

Is this fair? Thank you!

[kitsuwn]

Is this a fair trade for my Red Malk Dragon?

Please? qwq

This is definitely unfair to you. Most people wouldn't trade such a high demand list pet for random off-list pets anyway, but even if youre looking for a quantity trade down, this is still unfair to you rarity wise. IIRC, tier 1 september lists are worth around 25 '09 rares, but their side only adds up to around 16 and some misc from the newer commons/uncommons (even including the value of store pets & re-releases-- i'd value this at maybe 20 '09 rares total because of the demand for the pps fox, but not much more than that). This isn't even including the value of demand, and red malk dragons tend to go for quite a bit more than that anyway. You could get a better offer pretty easily.

Alright, thank you!

[Syn_cat]

are these trades fair?
trade 1

trade 2

[Kitkat2716]

Okay so would the 2018 uncommon and very common + the goat plushie and acrobatic ghosts be equal to the military outfit?

hoop

[SeriousBusiness]

Urgent!

Sunjewel + PPS Blue Malk dragon + 2000c$ for my sunback??
I know the sunjewel is tier 1 mainlist but since it's discontinued im not exactly sure what's it worth now
opinions? would you accept? is the sunjewel and pps malk easy to trade off? and how much do they add up? thank you!

[Vanhishikha]

Is this fair? Thank you for any help/assistance!