The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Airiss]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84870938&userid=859213&signature=3LjpDP4EHf3m7NxPzIEbmg

I know pink sorbet is worth more now. But is UR Bengal worth the same or more?
Thanks for help!

[XxDragonScalesxX]

Hi! I wasn't really sure where to ask this, but I got this trade and I have to ask for what I'd like. I have no idea what these pets are worth as they were new Halloween pets and I'm being asked to trade for non-Halloween ones.

They're asking for 5 token deers, two 4 token butterfly wolf things and a rare from easter.

I've traded with this person a few times before and know they don't really know rarities well, and I don't want to be unfair to either of us. Thank you for the help, and I'm sorry if I should have posted this somewhere else!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84865993&userid=889194&signature=b1ijPUlvaWmw-T44f7kKSA

Edit: I also just got this trade for 8 of the Halloween deer for some very old pets, help would be appreciated for this too!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84871855&userid=889194&signature=E8H1RjrxZWh6heEx1fltgA

I agree with Elwynie that the first one is unfair to you however if you use the 2:1 ratio a 2019 rare would be equal to a 2017 common. Though you might keep in mind that most people prefer to trade rares for rares.

As for the second trade the other person is overpaying by a huge amount. Those deer at max would only be worth around a 2016 rare and that's only if they turn out to be a rare.

[Elwynie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84870938&userid=859213&signature=3LjpDP4EHf3m7NxPzIEbmg

I know pink sorbet is worth more now. But is UR Bengal worth the same or more?
Thanks for help!

The pink sorb = 1 non
The Bengal = 1-1.5 nons

It would be a fair trade if you value the bengal at 1 non

[SunRaes]

Do you guys think this is fair? I know that, in terms of rarity, I'm sure I'm overpaying, but I'm more interested in the demand. (I'm the side with the rats and Cinnabun.) Thank you in advance!

[glitter]

?

already accepted the trade but I want to see if it was fair
pls respond its been six pages

[Elwynie]

Do you guys think this is fair? I know that, in terms of rarity, I'm sure I'm overpaying, but I'm more interested in the demand. (I'm the side with the rats and Cinnabun.) Thank you in advance!

The liontails = 2 nons <3 nons max>
The Cinnabun = 1-2 nons
The OMGSR Rats = sorb to a non (but it depends on who you trade with because rats have terrible demand)

It depends how you value your pets that make this trade fair or unfair(:

?

already accepted the trade but I want to see if it was fair
pls respond its been six pages

It takes a bit to get back to these sort of trades because some people arent great with bulk(: patience is key!
I would say it was unfair to them
A VR 09 = 2 09 rares
The C$ was a mass overpay..guess someone really wanted the set!

[SunRaes]

Do you guys think this is fair? I know that, in terms of rarity, I'm sure I'm overpaying, but I'm more interested in the demand. (I'm the side with the rats and Cinnabun.) Thank you in advance!

The liontails = 2 nons <3 nons max>
The Cinnabun = 1-2 nons
The OMGSR Rats = sorb to a non (but it depends on who you trade with because rats have terrible demand)

It depends how you value your pets that make this trade fair or unfair(:

Alright, thanks so much! Second opinions? (Trade is on my previous post)

[Spine]

Is this fair? I'm horrible with items. I know all the freebies are worth 2019 commons but what about the candycorn?

[XxDragonScalesxX]

Is this fair? I'm horrible with items. I know all the freebies are worth 2019 commons but what about the candycorn?

Unfair to you. Even if you value each item at a very common from this year your side would equal a little over 3 2018 rares. Also I'd say that the candycorn are worth about an uncommon from 2019 as they're a bit like animal eggs from Easter.

[Elwynie]

Is this fair? I'm horrible with items. I know all the freebies are worth 2019 commons but what about the candycorn?

Unfair to you. Even if you value each item at a very common from this year your side would equal a little over 3 2018 rares. Also I'd say that the candycorn are worth about an uncommon from 2019 as they're a bit like animal eggs from Easter.

You can also ask/check item worth here: What is This Item Worth?