The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[iguana]

trade I got

Is this fair? I'm still going by the list despite it's discontinuation, is this okay?

[SeaCrest]

trade I got

Is this fair? I'm still going by the list despite it's discontinuation, is this okay?

Lexi Cake Dog is a Tier 8 September list.

According to the gaps list, a Tier 8 September is worth a Tier 4 September 4 + 29-34 mixed '09 rares.

Scarf PPS is Tier 4 September, Fireworks PPS is Tier 1 Advent, Brown Red-String Horse is Tier 4 Advent.

A Tier 4 Advent comes to 5-6 mixed '09 rares, a Tier 1 Advent comes to 3-4 mixed '09 rares, which doesn't add enough to the Scarf PPS to make it fair, by the exact values in the old list. Demand may have changed!

[impenguin2]

Is this fair to me?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83879480&userid=5552&signature=TdW0dvIPr5J85_S_hjUG2A

[Vylad]

Hey, I'm uncertain if this one is fair, can someone help me out? Could someone please tell me what I need to add/remove?

You're about halfway there - a '14 rare is 64 '18 VCs, if I did math right.

Thanks a bunch! I really appreciate, But just a small question, it's a '14 uncommon? Is demand making it worth a '14 rare? Is 32 '18 VCs for a '14 uncommon?

[IonicFlare]

Is this fair at all???

[Tindraake]

What about this one?

[SeaCrest]

Thanks a bunch! I really appreciate, But just a small question, it's a '14 uncommon? Is demand making it worth a '14 rare? Is 32 '18 VCs for a '14 uncommon?

Sorry, I mistyped - I meant a '14 uncommon, not a '14 rare!

[Kadmos]

So someone is wiling to trade some items and we are tryng to work a fair trade ^^"
Unfortunately its not so easy to exchange pets for items so i am wondering if this offer is alright and how should it be changed to be a fair offer for the items?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83880276&userid=864607&signature=auxi9ElHlgLLrysiUgtAbw

[Oscurio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83879590&userid=711966&signature=IDsw_Ccjb7OfjJxnf_5t7g

Fair rarity and demand wise?

[Maligator]

So someone is wiling to trade some items and we are tryng to work a fair trade ^^"
Unfortunately its not so easy to exchange pets for items so i am wondering if this offer is alright and how should it be changed to be a fair offer for the items?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83880276&userid=864607&signature=auxi9ElHlgLLrysiUgtAbw

The map alone is worth more than everything on your side ;w; the map goes for main lists, I’ve seen at least sorbets for it in my experience.