The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83659010&userid=962650&signature=nTXI0oOj6QEG3A5U1tCGyg

Is this a fair trade? If not, who is under and by how much? Thank you!

Rarity wise it's unfair to you considering your pet is omgsr and their pet is only vr. Demand would be up to you, but I personally still see it as unfair to you

[quisicorazon]

Which of these bids would be better?:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83638569&userid=686260&signature=2VwpzDkUoQP6J_D_coaWWg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83576631&userid=686260&signature=d6pqUFGCV2VYc9PglyNg3w

[Yeens]

please help list demand wise (sorb worth)

[Spacer's Choice]

DIY cake auction again! Second place edited their bid and I was hoping to get an opinion or two? Thanks!

Bid 1 - This is the current winning bid.

Bid 2 - Updated second place bid. The main difference is the added UR Grapes instead of the store pets and 08/09 very rares from their previous bid

[tremolite]

i am bad at pet worths. im even worse at item worths,,,

are st. pat's socks fair for a rat butterfly tail? ;;

okay i got another trade with items and im still not good with item worth so:

is 30C$ fair for a rat butterfly tail, grass (front of basket), and black smoke contacts? which one is a better trade? ;;

[pochita]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83650355&userid=901300&signature=56-39cB5nLJNiFVB5maeZw
For a Moonswirl?
Thanks in advance

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83651580&userid=610178&signature=itajH1Bh1oGc-L2EAipT9Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83651970&userid=610178&signature=rfLq7UiaKWmEWtQfT2NC1w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83652369&userid=610178&signature=TZFfhp72IIn5B7cItI_Iwg

which of these would be the best offer?

Straight rarity wise, the third offer (with the nick horse) is the best. However, the second trade has two warrior cats, which are quite valuable and worth more in demand than their face value. I would take the second trade, personally. The warrior cats are pretty easy to trade off or sell.

i am bad at pet worths. im even worse at item worths,,,

are st. pat's socks fair for a rat butterfly tail? ;;

okay i got another trade with items and im still not good with item worth so:

is 30C$ fair for a rat butterfly tail, grass (front of basket), and black smoke contacts? which one is a better trade? ;;

st. pat's socks are underpay for a rat butterfly tail - socks were from early 2011, the rat butterfly tail is from late 2009.

I would call 30 C$ for those items overpay on their side, but I don't know about demand.

[Mellø]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83659819&userid=956683&signature=DpFdBRUx60iA3724kGFspQ is this fair? if im being honest, i dont really think it is.

[Guest]

DIY cake auction again! Second place edited their bid and I was hoping to get an opinion or two? Thanks!

Bid 1 - This is the current winning bid.

Bid 2 - Updated second place bid. The main difference is the added UR Grapes instead of the store pets and 08/09 very rares from their previous bid

In my opinion, they’re equal as good. The first bid includes 4 nons of worth (Liontail = 2, patchwork = 1.5, punk = 0.5) The second includes around 4 as well (3 from BEG + CEG set, 0.5-1 from grape, and a bit over 0.5 from tribal + add) They’re around equal

[SeaCrest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83659819&userid=956683&signature=DpFdBRUx60iA3724kGFspQ is this fair? if im being honest, i dont really think it is.

If using a item = 1 uncommon from the same year, technically they're ever-so-slightly overpaying, but I personally would not take it. The bulk of the trade is in very commons, and honestly the value is only made up by the items. Items are harder to trade off, imo, and you could get much better pet offers for your '09 rares.