The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[JJdiner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83381292&userid=949329&signature=-iRz2xiDs9CmnrLOVldoDw

Pretty sure something needs to be added to their side, but I'm not sure how much.

Thanks in advance!

actually they are overpaying by an 09 and a half (ignoring the newer pets on your side as they don't add up to 09s

[amarok.]

this ?
thank you ,

oh, that's quite a fun one. if we value each of those larger turtles as a '12 uncommon, that'll make them worth a '14 rare or so. even ignoring the other items that's a pretty solid trade to you.

id actualy say your side is overpay, maybe 2.5 '10s so they should add a 2010 rare, 2011 rare, 1 2014, + whatever is the value of the tag

but 43 tiny turtles? yo that's pretty crazy. say we value each one as a '12 vc. that adds up to 21.5 commons, or ~ 10 uncommons, or roughly 3 '11 rares. that's 1.5 '10 rares, plus 0.5 '10 rares from the larger turtles. that's approximately 2 '10 rares if we're conservative. still standing by the opinion this is a pretty fair trade.
who even has that many turtles



edit; typo.

[Stripe12]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83381292&userid=949329&signature=-iRz2xiDs9CmnrLOVldoDw

Pretty sure something needs to be added to their side, but I'm not sure how much.

Thanks in advance!

actually they are overpaying by an 09 and a half (ignoring the newer pets on your side as they don't add up to 09s

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83381292&userid=949329&signature=-iRz2xiDs9CmnrLOVldoDw

Pretty sure something needs to be added to their side, but I'm not sure how much.

Thanks in advance!

actually, their lions are store pets and worth a 2010 rare each, so they are overpaying by quite a bit.

Thank you both! Didn't know they were that valuable lol

[Reki.]

Would love some advice as what would a fair trade as far as C$ or FR Gems for a Skelebun and Orange Cerberus?

[JJdiner]

-snip -

Thank you both! Didn't know they were that valuable lol

i agree that it is crazy, but i would personally still value them as an uncommon '12 each, how you value them is ultimately up to you though according to the items thread i believe most items can be valued as a common or uncommon from that year

[amarok.]

Would love some advice as what would a fair trade as far as C$ or FR Gems for a Skelebun and Orange Cerberus?

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876
try asking here c:

[madisong]

Would love some advice as what would a fair trade as far as C$ or FR Gems for a Skelebun and Orange Cerberus?

The last orange cerberus & skelebun I’ve seen traded for 30,000 gems each (:

[Trickz]

Light Leopard + Dark Leopard + ?? = Winged Wood Dog

What needs to be added to make this fair?

Can I get some more opinions?

[snowdrake]

-snip -

Thank you both! Didn't know they were that valuable lol

i agree that it is crazy, but i would personally still value them as an uncommon '12 each, how you value them is ultimately up to you though according to the items thread i believe most items can be valued as a common or uncommon from that year

@JJdiner I think you mixed up the trades here. they were talking about the store lion trade and not the item trade lol

just to make it clear, all recent store pets are worth a 2010 rare each! anything less is underpay.

[suguru]

How about this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83382036&userid=855246&signature=cbyPLOfAPCfh0HL0SOYdeQ