The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

I have a trade I'd like looked at please. I'm on the fence on this one, and would like other opinions. Big trades with a lot of variables sometimes make me want to cancel outright...

They're overpaying, the two 2010 rares are fair for your 2016 store pet, the 2011 rare is fair for your rare 2011 halloween re-release (the batdog), and the rest of the pets on their side would be overpay for a 2014 rare, uncommon, and common.

[Saddened]

I wanted to know how fair this was?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83272511&userid=609399&signature=y42Ak8Mq8_alKBVCPc7fXA

I’m not too sure on worth of items as much as i do some pets.

[Trickz]

Winged Wood Angel + Angel Advent + Brown Collie = ??

List-wise, please! I'd love a rarity and demand answer if possible.

List wise, they would add up to almost a Line Tribal. You could probably get more considering the Angel Advent and Winged Wood Angel have good demand -- but I don't know exactly what you'd be able to get for them "demand wise".

Thanks so much! Can I get a second opinion?

[DaBrat438]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83275277&userid=715379&signature=6bNUInUKzZzi34bWsGMU4w

I know this is not fair but I am willing to take the event pets for the deer but I have no clue how many would be fair to ask for?

[darzie]

So this is quite a monster of a trade, but I want an opinion if this would be fair without the items involved: trades/viewtrade.php?id=83267570&userid=1509&signature=fdEczci1qm5MtqE3qsy9bQ

[Ginneh]

Is this fair?

[alphias]

Is this fair?

I personally would say it’s unfair to you due to rarity and that ur side is a number of store pets. I’ve seen those particular store pets go for a lot. I’m not sure how the bunny on their side is valued. They’re offering recent event pets too.

[Vilhelm]

Which is best? How can the others improve?
Bid 1

Bid 2

Bid 3

[UnworthyElevator]

Please help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83267418&userid=840388&signature=xrARh2cRkc9H8aPSBol0KQ

[♥HazelNightmare]

Please help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83267418&userid=840388&signature=xrARh2cRkc9H8aPSBol0KQ

Both within 3 month ,both have decent demand in my opinion as one is malk and other warrior. It’s up to you which you prefer and if you prefer true date over rerelease or value warriors higher .