The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Puptarts]

Very sorry! Is this better?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81151536&userid=964094&signature=zFvTz2zCQ6AH4jSdnip55A

It's unfair to you. The pocky is worth a '08 R/VR while your side adds up to 4 '09 rares, not sure where the bun is from though.

[Kittytalia]

Is this fair? Taking demand into account too?

[luca_balsa]

Is this fair? We have been going back and forth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81154283&userid=821137&signature=sIz3UIumZGEA5XoBifbOxQ

[Ironic Equation]

Hi! Could I get any opinions on these trades/whether you would personally accept and which one?
One
Two
Three
I'd love an opinion on these trades? I know someone answered but I'd like an answer based on current values rather than the list, since I've seen the joker bun and GWJ go for more than list value since the rarity change.

Also this one, which I am very very tempted by.

[nobxdy]

Hi! Could I get any opinions on these trades/whether you would personally accept and which one[s]?
One
Two
Three
I'd love an opinion on these trades? I know someone answered but I'd like an answer based on current values rather than the list, since I've seen the joker bun and GWJ go for more than list value since the rarity change.

I personally wouldn't trade a Non for any of those trades as I literally value each of their pets (joker bunny/pineapple/GWJ) at 1-2 Sorbets, mostly leaning towards 1 Sorbet, because I just don't think they're very desirable. However, demand is completely up to you and your trading partner to decide. I have seen some people value the Joker Bunny and GWJ around a Non, but like I said, it varies.

Is this fair? We have been going back and forth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81154283&userid=821137&signature=sIz3UIumZGEA5XoBifbOxQ

If you still trade by the list, it's very unfair to you -- if you don't trade by the list or don't agree with their values, then it's up to you to decide how you personally value your side vs their Patchwork.

If you want my opinion, I see this as unfair to them. The Patchwork (from what I seen) can get a Sorbet-Non's worth, and I just don't see your side being worth that much especially with the quantity.

[Cynical Rage]

Is this fair?
Thank you!

[skyline]

Is this fair? Taking demand into account too?

i'd personally accept this. the holly seems to have a slight bit more demand than the bun, and has been omgsr for much longer. as the bun only changed after the feb '19 overhaul.

Is this fair? We have been going back and forth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81154283&userid=821137&signature=sIz3UIumZGEA5XoBifbOxQ

the patchwork has been going for around a non lately, sometimes more if you're patient. i personally value your side at a high ex september to a lowish ex main. i own 2 patchworks, and i would personally keep mine. though how you value your store pets, and the patchwork, is ultimately up to you c:

Is this fair?
Thank you!

list wise, it's unfair to you. rarity wise, i personally value their side at just about a non or a bit under, and the holly at a solid non. the rat is tricky considering you can never put too much hope into what you want to get for it. because of that, i'd pass, although for the most part this offer is very solid, and it is up to you, and how you value the pets involved.

[madisong]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81154860&userid=939791&signature=BvUYGGjnIZLMvMXQoc7MGQ
would this be fair? Im not sure how much my item is worth

[polyphon]

is this fair?

i also got offered this

any help is appreciated <3

[Syn_cat]

is this fair?