The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[the]

Hi, ive received a few offers for items that I'm struggling to decide on! If anyone could let me know if these are fair or not that would be great c:
trade 1
trade 2
trade 3

The first trade is very unfair to you. The lipstick kiss, birthday balloon and horse plushie are worth at least a '09 rare/very rare each.

[candor.]

Hi, ive received a few offers for items that I'm struggling to decide on! If anyone could let me know if these are fair or not that would be great c:
trade 1
trade 2
trade 3

The first trade is very unfair to you. The lipstick kiss, birthday balloon and horse plushie are worth at least a '09 rare/very rare each.

ah, i had no idea! thank you for letting me know c:

[General Chaos]

How are these trades? Do i need to add?

First Trade

Second Trade

[the]

How are these trades? Do i need to add?

First Trade

Second Trade

You're overpaying in the second trade. Your pet is two years older than theirs :)

[it depends]

How are these trades? Do i need to add?

First Trade

Second Trade

imo you're overpaying in both trades; i personally value a 19' store pet for a 10' rare.
in the second; i don't believe the 13' pet is a rerelease. so it's unfair to you date wise.

[Cynical Rage]

Is this fair at all?
Thank you!

[honey bees]

How are these trades? Do i need to add?

First Trade

Second Trade

Rarity-wise, you would be overpaying since a '19 store pet is usually worth a late '10 rare and their side is equivalent to 1 '09 rare + '10 rare. Your side has 2 '09 rares + '10 rare + '11 rare

In the second trade, your pet is 2 years older than the pet you're trading for so you would be overpaying.

[♥HazelNightmare]

Is this fair at all?
Thank you!

Very unfair to the dragon list and demand wise. Your is a mid advent and adds while the dragon is a September list, main list with demand ( subjective )

[Ashara]

Around how many nons is their side worth?

[Gympie]

Was this a good bid? I won it, but was curious as to see if I overed, undered, etc (i have never done an auction before, how did I win)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81333066&userid=950685&signature=wCHHAS4FHcJ1qNmNWeBY4g