The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81331915&userid=964094&signature=htI8-QJi7KZCZheKDrQ9gw

Fair? I would love a quick answer please

Rarity wise they're overpaying with the items, without the items it's about fair
Demand is up to you but I would personally keep your store pets

[Jained]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81332079&userid=827874&signature=rd_GJA5p_bJIRh5P41nUUA

?

[GreenteaLatte]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81329234&userid=224744&signature=yLYm_xm1gF96tcFj2sCQ9g

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81329735&userid=224744&signature=KxSrf4KSTCVvn8l8BkS6Cg

wondering if these are fair?

I don't know about the first one but the second one is unfair to the top. Your caramel apple is a '10 Halloween item and their Pumpkin carry bag and Vampire Fangs are also from '10 Halloween.
Large Silver Crown and Small Silver Crown are an '11 store items, Floaty blue and pink wings are '10 store items and Katana is a '09 store item + '11 UC dog.
I don't know about the apple demand but it's a big overpay on their side.

Thanks! I'd like one more opinion c:

[QueenPebbles93]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81331943&userid=947682&signature=Gvo5QoPOLdfTjMbx3ETWLA

Can someone help! I’m not good with C$!

[negati]

Me again! Just a quick question before I finalize an auction. Which is a better offer? What is the King dog worth? Someone already confirmed for the me the rat is worth a sorb. Is the King worth more than that, or much less?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81319861&userid=44306&signature=f5MHIfXi9HnmD5m09bCzFg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81332172&userid=44306&signature=1oyBD4eHLzWiCTRQuLsgqA

[Gympie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81331943&userid=947682&signature=Gvo5QoPOLdfTjMbx3ETWLA

Can someone help! I’m not good with C$!

Im not too sure but I think they are under, your side is worth more. Again, I am not sure, I am somewhat sure of this. Sorry >~<

[Gympie]

Opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81332628&userid=950685&signature=4PJiedYavSmJvAbUF7jCoA

[QueenPebbles93]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81331943&userid=947682&signature=Gvo5QoPOLdfTjMbx3ETWLA

Can someone help! I’m not good with C$!

Im not too sure but I think they are under, your side is worth more. Again, I am not sure, I am somewhat sure of this. Sorry >~<

It’s alright! Thank you! I was thinking that their side was under! Can I get a second opinion?

[Emi_]

Opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81332628&userid=950685&signature=4PJiedYavSmJvAbUF7jCoA

I would say this is unfair to them. The warrior cats have good demand but 75 C$ is generally worth a tier 2-3 advent list pet. The C$ alone is overpay, not counting the pets added and the '09 scarf.

[ithiria]

Me again! Just a quick question before I finalize an auction. Which is a better offer? What is the King dog worth? Someone already confirmed for the me the rat is worth a sorb. Is the King worth more than that, or much less?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81319861&userid=44306&signature=f5MHIfXi9HnmD5m09bCzFg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81332172&userid=44306&signature=1oyBD4eHLzWiCTRQuLsgqA

the card dog is worth much less than a sorbet, its no list pet, its just a '08 very rare, with a good demand though.
the rat is/was a september list pet, in my opinion it's not worth a sorbet and i NEVER paid or received a sorbets worth for any omgsr rat (except the UR rat), but of course, since it turned omgsr, some people might overpay, still rats have a bad demand and are very hard to trade off.