The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Jelissa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78174133&userid=148141&signature=7p0Qp7Z4McvehvsIaEreoQ

Is it fair?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80984030&userid=800528&signature=KWgpHfOQnjp3s2UJzJhnVg

please help

A 2015 store pet is worth a mid 2009 rare. 2009 rares are generally valued at 2 rares from 2010.
Your 2013 and 2016 rares do not add up to another 2010 rare, so it was unfair to the store pet.
Any demand is up to you and your trading partner as demand varies from user to user. c:

[emrys]

Could I get more advice on this bid? I’d value their offer at around 1.5 nons

Boop

[honeycreeper]

does this look pretty fair? what's the demand on the UR Foal? thanks so much for any help!

how is this offer? it also includes the UR Foal!

honey

could i have a few more opinions please :>
what's the demand on the UR Foal? could i get a UR Bee with it?

[Jelissa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78174133&userid=148141&signature=7p0Qp7Z4McvehvsIaEreoQ

Is it fair?

[rats!]

Hello! Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80982720&userid=22963&signature=3mG0xxmfd_AFaahWD0D8Hw

[popping star]

Hello! Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80982720&userid=22963&signature=3mG0xxmfd_AFaahWD0D8Hw

This is pretty fair to both sides of the trade!
(Here's the 'How much is this pet worth in C$?' thread.)

Mid 2010 rare (Guinea pig) = 25-30 C$
Early 2010 rare = 30-35 C$
Mid 2009 rare/very rare = 40-45 C$
TOTAL = 95-110 C$

How you personally value pets in C$ is up to you. c:

[Lothlórien]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

[popping star]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

If you still go by the retired list, some users do, this could be considered pretty unfair to you. The raven dog tends to fetch around 1.5-2 nons. (It could fetch more or less. It really depends on who you trade.) The top of the trade adds up to around a blue toxic. The list quantity is nice, but I personally wouldn't value their side at anything more than a purple toxic. It really depends on how you personally value the involved pets though! Any demand is up to you as demand varies from user to user. ^^

If you don't use the retired list, it's up to you how you value the involved pets.

[Lothlórien]

Thoughts On This Trade?
I was just starting to understand everything with trades and now with the List Pets getting "booted" I have no idea about anything :? . I'm guessing demand is about the same regardless? Anyway I would love some thoughts on this trade! :)

If you still go by the retired list, some users do, this could be considered pretty unfair to you. The raven dog tends to fetch around 1.5-2 nons. (It could fetch more or less. It really depends on who you trade.) The top of the trade adds up to around a blue toxic. The list quantity is nice, but I personally wouldn't value their side at anything more than a purple toxic. It really depends on how you personally value the involved pets though! Any demand is up to you as demand varies from user to user. ^^

If you don't use the retired list, it's up to you how you value the involved pets.

Thanks, this helps.