The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SeriousBusiness]

is this fair? thank you in advance!

is this fair thank you in advance

is this fair? thank you in advance!

is this fair thank you in advance
First trade looks about fair imo, the new store pets go for a late 2010 rare each. Your pet is worth a mid 09 rare.

Second trade your side is over , the pet they are offering you is worth 4-5 09 rares using list , your side worth 7 09 rares 2011 uncommon and 2012 common ( that’s including the horse item )

thank you! for the second trade though what should i take off my side to make it fair? any pet would do but like what do you prefer removing? (that includes the item too)

[♥HazelNightmare]

is this fair? thank you in advance!

is this fair thank you in advance

is this fair? thank you in advance!

is this fair thank you in advance
First trade looks about fair imo, the new store pets go for a late 2010 rare each. Your pet is worth a mid 09 rare.

Second trade your side is over , the pet they are offering you is worth 4-5 09 rares using list , your side worth 7 09 rares 2011 uncommon and 2012 common ( that’s including the horse item )

thank you! for the second trade though what should i take off my side to make it fair? any pet would do but like what do you prefer removing? (that includes the item too)

Any 2 09 rares would be fine or the last two pets and the horse item ( Store pet and Malk horse, it’s an 09 rerelease )

[♥HazelNightmare]

how does this trade look? I don’t follow the old list when it comes to my store pets. But I just want some other people’s opinions?

All depends where you value the patch work at , some value it at a 1-1.5 nons some less some more, you have the sorbet and the punk which can fetch up to a sorbet . Seems like the sun back has been around 2-3 nons lately. So if you value the patchwork highly those three pets would be 2.5 nons . There are a few other lower advents added too .
Of course feel free to get a second option as demand fluctuates a lot lately with this older store pets.

[honeycreeper]

does this look pretty fair? what's the demand on the UR Foal? thanks so much for any help!

how is this offer? it also includes the UR Foal!

honey

could i have a few more opinions please :>
what's the demand on the UR Foal? could i get a UR Bee with it?

[GreenteaLatte]

how does this trade look? I don’t follow the old list when it comes to my store pets. But I just want some other people’s opinions?

All depends where you value the patch work at , some value it at a 1-1.5 nons some less some more, you have the sorbet and the punk which can fetch up to a sorbet . Seems like the sun back has been around 2-3 nons lately. So if you value the patchwork highly those three pets would be 2.5 nons . There are a few other lower advents added too .
Of course feel free to get a second option as demand fluctuates a lot lately with this older store pets.

I believe only the Lolita goes for a sorb. The other punks goes for around a september list as far as I know. Other than that I agree with Hazeldreamer.

[Asuna_Yuuki_94]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80983856&userid=686522&signature=xyTw-V7B1AlaN0bdbmmhqw
Is this fair? Thank you!

[GreenteaLatte]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80983856&userid=686522&signature=xyTw-V7B1AlaN0bdbmmhqw
Is this fair? Thank you!

It's unfair to the top. The top is worth around 3~4 09 rares while the bottom is worth 1.

[♥HazelNightmare]

how does this trade look? I don’t follow the old list when it comes to my store pets. But I just want some other people’s opinions?

All depends where you value the patch work at , some value it at a 1-1.5 nons some less some more, you have the sorbet and the punk which can fetch up to a sorbet . Seems like the sun back has been around 2-3 nons lately. So if you value the patchwork highly those three pets would be 2.5 nons . There are a few other lower advents added too .
Of course feel free to get a second option as demand fluctuates a lot lately with this older store pets.

I believe only the Lolita goes for a sorb. The other punks goes for around a september list as far as I know. Other than that I agree with Hazeldreamer.

Yes it’s been fluctuating a lot lately the punk dogs , a few months ago just the Lolita and now I see all punks go anywhere from high advent to sorbet , it’s crazy the demand of some of these and what users will pay for them ( especially in auctions ) the androids I’ve noticed the same with them too 💕

[popping star]

Just for reference, how was this?.. trades/viewtrade.php?id=80983028&userid=675160&signature=qKVACscsYOg9-_70VbXqkQ

The top side of the trade adds up to a low September list at best. (This is going by actual worth. All warriors had extended releases.) The full warrior set often goes for a main list. Their side doesn't have the full set, so I personally see this as unfair to you. Even with demand, I personally wouldn't value their side any higher than a mid-high September list. It really depends on how you and your trading personally value the involved pets though!

If you don't go by the list and value lists like regular rares, it's pretty unfair to the top. Your side is only worth 5 2009 rares as 2008 very rares are generally valued at 2 2009 rares + a 2010 rare.

[☆Lil Peep☆]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80984030&userid=800528&signature=KWgpHfOQnjp3s2UJzJhnVg

please help