The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80969049&userid=947682&signature=8BcDhJ9P6pEaa_eHeOFcXA


trades/viewtrade.php?id=80970939&userid=947682&signature=gukZEfuvUINAoKle9Ph_ug

Are these 2 trades fair?

1. I believe it's unfair to them because their rat is worth 2 '09 rares, and your store pet is only worth 1 '09 rare. I don't think the items add up to another '09 rare, but I'm not an expert on items so please get another opinion on this!

2. Unfair to you. Their side is worth 2 '09 rares, your side is worth 3 '09 rares. Demand is up to you. c:

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971112&userid=763673&signature=VEK4qjgJkwMR3X6MzQ0AcA

Your side = 2 early 2009 rares
Their side = 1 early 2009 rare + 1 late 2009 rare
You could consider it unfair to you due to the other one being outside of the 3 month rule, but if you don't care about date gaps then you could see this as fair.

[bleujaykinq]

This fair? ^^

[popping star]

This fair? ^^

It's unfair to the top. The top of the trade is worth 1 2009 rare OR 2 2010 rares.
Your side adds up to 1 2010 rare + a bit over a 2015 rare at most. (2015 R = 2 2015 UC = 1 2014 UC = 2013 C)
Any demand is up to you and your trading partner! (As a note, I used the 2:1 ratio.)

If you don't use rarity math and value all rares the same regardless of date, it's unfair to you.

[iago.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971081&userid=964094&signature=_ghf_tSquLgKYFKlzwTZUw

Opinions on this trade?

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971081&userid=964094&signature=_ghf_tSquLgKYFKlzwTZUw

Opinions on this trade?

It's unfair to the C$ alone. Your side only adds up to a little over 110C$.

[g.alex.y]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971276&userid=812671&signature=8eoLcKnV0_75YuzsokRCmQ
Just a little help would be great!

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971276&userid=812671&signature=8eoLcKnV0_75YuzsokRCmQ
Just a little help would be great!

Your store pet is worth a mid-late 2009 rare as it released from late 2015 into early 2016.
They're offering you a late 2009 rare, so it's fair if you value both sides at a late 2009 rare.
If you value your store pet at a mid 2009 rare, it's a bit unfair to you. Demand is up to you. c:

[luca_balsa]

Some help please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971076&userid=821137&signature=MewdLILa3kD6_cZzm76r2w

[nobxdy]

Some help please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971076&userid=821137&signature=MewdLILa3kD6_cZzm76r2w

It would be unfair to them -- their side is worth almost a Main List (if you go by the list)
It's still unfair to them even if you go by years. Just one of the Advent dogs would be fair.

[~Wandere~]

I am not sure if this is fair, Please help me out
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80971625&userid=815931&signature=xvl0eTCpsEWMCBj13m320g