The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kkspecial4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80627075&userid=952637&signature=d-zK-6Z2-4HC2i9H1gZ0qA
Is this fair? Would you guys take this? If not which side would have to add how much?

Also just got this offer:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80725055&userid=952637&signature=AgOhFUq6pbKgpkcQpNsgDg
Same questions for this k e as the first

I already answered the first trade on the top of pg. 312

The second trade is fair - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trade partner
Also up to you on which pet you prefer

2009 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares
2013 Store Pet (Llama) = 2 2009 Rares

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80724957&userid=788126&signature=0J-kiBOS7CVByAhhUBYO_Q is this a fair trade please? I don't know what is this item worth

Unfair to the item side
Weretomato2 I believe is valued roughly around 1 2010 Uncommon/Rare now, but can fetch more depending on the person trading
Feel free to ask more about item worth here

[ruthless]

Should I consider any of these bids? Thank you!

• Bid 1
  
• Bid 2
• Bid 3
• Bid 4

[Spearow]

Should I consider any of these bids? Thank you!

• Bid 1
  
• Bid 2
• Bid 3
• Bid 4

If you still follow the list, I would personally be tempted by bid one and four. In terms of demand, I think most people prefer the cinnabun over the pickle/cumber. Tribals are difficult in my experience to trade. And with that black advent or red dragon I know people often will pay way more than they are worth in regards to the list.

Get a second opinion as I still go by the list.

[fιяєfℓу]

Should I consider any of these bids? Thank you!

• Bid 1
  
• Bid 2
• Bid 3
• Bid 4

If you still follow the list, I would personally be tempted by bid one and four. In terms of demand, I think most people prefer the cinnabun over the pickle/cumber. Tribals are difficult in my experience to trade. And with that black advent or red dragon I know people often will pay way more than they are worth in regards to the list.

Get a second opinion as I still go by the list.

Bid one is definitely the best. Cinnabun tens to go for 1.5-2 nons and has good demand.
Pickle and tribals have bad demand as the ba isnt true date so it would go for about 1-2 sorbets

[Ashara]

Is this fair please?

It's unfair to the balloon dog when following the list.
Going by the retired list, your side is worth roughly the grey dragon tier on the Sept. list.
The balloon dog is on the main list. Any demand and how you value quantity is up to you. c:

If you value lists like regular rares, the balloon dog is worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare.
Your floppy pink September alone would be enough as it's also worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare.

Thanks for your help!

Can I get another opinion? Would like to know what needs to be added to make it fair.

[ruthless]

Should I consider any of these bids? Thank you!

• Bid 1
  
• Bid 2
• Bid 3
• Bid 4

If you still follow the list, I would personally be tempted by bid one and four. In terms of demand, I think most people prefer the cinnabun over the pickle/cumber. Tribals are difficult in my experience to trade. And with that black advent or red dragon I know people often will pay way more than they are worth in regards to the list.

Get a second opinion as I still go by the list.

Can I get another opinion?

[kkspecial4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80727506&userid=961803&signature=UypE-o4oUnkrOl62FEA7YA
Is this fair?

Slightly unfair to the top - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner

The Warrior Cats are from September 2009 - however they had an extended release into April 2010, thus are only worth 1 Early 2010 Rare each - rarity wise

The top adds up to 1 2009 Rare + 1 2012 Uncommon
The bottom is worth 1 Late 2009 Rare

[Raya36]

I'm not too sure if this is fair
Is there a guide for selling pets for C$?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80724673&userid=769200&signature=qDaI3wkZ14yOj0M7qOqTDg

Thank you!

[kkspecial4]

I'm not too sure if this is fair
Is there a guide for selling pets for C$?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80724673&userid=769200&signature=qDaI3wkZ14yOj0M7qOqTDg

Thank you!

Unfair to the bottom
Demand is up to you and your trading partner to discuss and decide on

1 Mid 2009 Rare/Very Rare = 40-45 C$ each

Together both ponies are worth roughly 80-90 C$

C$ Worth Thread

[Raya36]

Thank you so much!