The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ghostbite]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help in advance!

[popping star]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help in advance!

Your aviator scarf is from Halloween 2015.
Their corn stalk is from Halloween 2013, and their pine is from Christmas 2015.
It's unfair to the top of the trade. How you personally value items is up to you. c:

[riptide17]

Thank you, odd eye! <3 I'll save the link and do my best to figure it out haha.

Would this be fair? If not, what needs to change? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80690524&userid=591123&signature=MTg7y3sglL8CawXJLb2kRw

[marshsiren]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80669297&userid=859271&signature=dHkifvpS5QF9zxc3ezFjWw
Hello I was wondering if this is fair, it contains items.
Thank you very much for any help (:[/quote][/quote][/quote][/quote]

[nobxdy]

Thank you, odd eye! <3 I'll save the link and do my best to figure it out haha.

Would this be fair? If not, what needs to change? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80690524&userid=591123&signature=MTg7y3sglL8CawXJLb2kRw

It's unfair to you -- their pets look a little too recent to be worth your side.
Your side is worth over 3.5 '09 rares. (:

[riptide17]

There isn't too much on their side that I would want to add, so what could I take out on my side to make it more even?

[Đ₳Ɽ₭ ₩ØⱠ₣]

2 OMGSCs for VC?
2 VCs for C? 4 OMGSCs for C?
2 Cs for UC? 4 VCs for UC? 8 OMGSCs for UC?
2 UCs for R? 4 Cs for R? 8 VCs for R? 16 OMGSCs for R?
2 Rs for VR? 4 UCs for VR? 8 Cs for VR? 16 VCs for R? 32 OMGSCs for VR?
2 VRs for OMGSR? 4 Rs for OMGSR? 8 UCs for OMGSR? 16 Cs for OMGSR? 32 VCs for OMGSR? 64 OMGSCs for OMGSR?

[Fishcat]

Would this be fair?

[popping star]

Would this be fair?

The C$ side is overpaying if you follow the list.
The target dog is valued at 160-180 C$. Demand is up to you. c:

[Đ₳Ɽ₭ ₩ØⱠ₣]

To fishnet: a bit overpriced... maybe for an OMGSR?