The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=57725475&userid=9355&signature=DBksxCIPfAmZPNchKOAaLA

If this isnt fair to rocket what year/rarity pet should be added?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=57725475&userid=9355&signature=DBksxCIPfAmZPNchKOAaLA

If this isnt fair to rocket what year/rarity pet should be added?

Your pet had an extended release until August 2009, so it's worth 1 '09 rare.
The other side needs to add another '10 rare or anything equivalent in value to their side. c:

Thanks, would this make it more fair???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80687646&userid=768234&signature=j9X8u4pZ9vVgHskSJDDaHA

If not, how much more should they add???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80682870&userid=768234&signature=nQ7ci1kwNp6Tbqfi-Ev8Rw

Is that one fair??

The first trade adds up to a high Sept. list or the lowest tier on the main list at most.
It's unfair to you as the pineapple goes for a sorbet up to a non.
Quantity has a value of its own, however, so it's up to you.

OMGSR rats tend to be valued at about a sorbet.
If you value your pineapple at a sorbet, it's about fair.
If you value your pineapple at anything higher, it's unfair to you.
Of course, any demand is up to you to decide. c:

[marshsiren]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80669297&userid=859271&signature=dHkifvpS5QF9zxc3ezFjWw
Hello I was wondering if this is fair, it contains items.
Thank you very much for any help (:

[Blue_Aussie]

They added to their side, is it close to fair now?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80688048&userid=768234&signature=2WTSXiY1CKt6GTEwjgk_kA

I don't value the pineapple very high

[popping star]

They added to their side, is it close to fair now?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80688048&userid=768234&signature=2WTSXiY1CKt6GTEwjgk_kA

I don't value the pineapple very high

The top adds up to roughly the red x pps or rose pps tier on the main list.
Depending on how you personally value your pineapple, it's either fair or unfair.
Demand and how you value quantity pets is up to you. c:

[slushpuppie]

PLEASE HELP :OO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
trade - UR malk dog for UR peach
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80688608&userid=877876&signature=PxVKd3J5uhw6YEre0B360g

[popping star]

PLEASE HELP :OO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
trade - UR malk dog for UR peach
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80688608&userid=877876&signature=PxVKd3J5uhw6YEre0B360g

The trade depends on how you value the UR peach as it has no set value.
It's worth somewhere between the UR holly dog and a non when using the list.
If you value both pets the same, it's fair. c:

[Vanrouge]

How do these 2 look? Thanks in advance for any help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80647335&userid=429963&signature=ACdM9MuBbfRjM4qbjTk1mQ

&

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80658656&userid=429963&signature=NpjGfNHhQyZH2qzm_tqGWQ

[Gummyash]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686717&userid=489295&signature=--3-T6j97-zpAiE6fv7LjQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686590&userid=489295&signature=0vGdf5VwMa6l_nhOjmEy5A

ty in advance!

[popping star]

How do these 2 look? Thanks in advance for any help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80647335&userid=429963&signature=ACdM9MuBbfRjM4qbjTk1mQ

&

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80658656&userid=429963&signature=NpjGfNHhQyZH2qzm_tqGWQ

1. Your side is worth 12-16 '09 rares when using the list.
The top is worth 14-17 '09 rares, 1 '13 R, 1 '14 R, 1 '15 R, 1 '16 R, 1 '17 R, and 2 '17 uncommons.

2. Your side is worth 14-18 '09 rares when using the list.
The red rose is worth about 33-40 '09 rares, so they're overpaying.

It's up to you whether you want to take either trade or not. Any demand is up to you. c: