The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[myworld1000]

I realize both are overpaying but who's overpaying the most?
1
Includes- A '18 store pet, 2 '11 items, 2 '12 items, 7 '13 items, 4 '14 items, and a '15 item
2
Includes- A '12 item, 19 '13 items, and 5 '14 items

wrong link! use the one on the bottom c:

Fixed! my bad I wasn't paying attention, but tysm for pointing it out <3

[Pasteli~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686656&userid=851004&signature=JoKHXDOLDHg-JU-jApPMxQ

Would 90 CS dollars be fair for these guys? They don't have much demand at all but they're kinda old so...

[Spinda]

Please help it's one of my dreamies I'm willing to over pay a bit but is this a re-leased date? Is it the same value?
Is this okay ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686671&userid=958822&signature=plc7e7M3zNRVGpGm2uKxAw

[myworld1000]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686656&userid=851004&signature=JoKHXDOLDHg-JU-jApPMxQ

Would 90 CS dollars be fair for these guys? They don't have much demand at all but they're kinda old so...

Unfair to you
4 '11 rares = 64-76 c$ (16-19 c$ each)
A late '10 rare = 20-25 c$
A mid '10 rare = 25-30 c$

Therefore your side equals between 109-131 c$

[myworld1000]

Please help it's one of my dreamies I'll willing to over pay a bit but is this a re-leased date? Is it the same value?
Is this okay ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686671&userid=958822&signature=plc7e7M3zNRVGpGm2uKxAw

It's a 12/18 pet so yes (personally I value a 12/18 pet the same as the original but some don't). The horse is originally from February of 2009. You are overpaying but keep in mind that some may not like trade downs and would prefer a rare for rare.

[Spinda]

Please help it's one of my dreamies I'll willing to over pay a bit but is this a re-leased date? Is it the same value?
Is this okay ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686671&userid=958822&signature=plc7e7M3zNRVGpGm2uKxAw

It's a 12/18 pet so yes (personally I value a 12/18 pet the same as the original but some don't). The horse is originally from February of 2009. You are overpaying but keep in mind that some may not like trade downs and would prefer a rare for rare.

I have it to where it's edit only. So should I cancel and resend taking out some pets especially couple horses? And just tell them that I had to cancel as I found out I was over paying too much and so i had to resend?

[Papilio Ulysses]

Fair? Opinions, please.

[myworld1000]

Fair? Opinions, please.

Unfair to you
Animal egg #53 was from Easter 2015 and the two plushies are from Halloween 2016. All items are worth a C-UC from the same year so at the most those three items would be worth a 2015 rare.

[Papilio Ulysses]

Fair? Opinions, please.

Unfair to you
Animal egg #53 was from Easter 2015 and the two plushies are from Halloween 2016. All items are worth a C-UC from the same year so at the most those three items would be worth a 2015 rare.

Indeed, I was thinking the items weren't quite enough for the 2012 rare - and I wasn't sure by how much. Thank you kindly for your very helpful response and insight.

[Spinda]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80686886&userid=958822&signature=0J7sWSh3-5leXpNSdiwNAQ

Okay so is this better especially what I said to them?