The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[enokimoon]

is this fair ?

I'm not good w items,,, :'0
tysm in advance !

[Gummyash]

no clue

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80685179&userid=489295&signature=aSwE3eNGCoUMIwDpOgS0Rg

[dogtreat]

no clue

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80685179&userid=489295&signature=aSwE3eNGCoUMIwDpOgS0Rg

the bricks are from 2014 egypt event and are worth a 2014 common each. so this is a fair trade ^^

is this fair ?

I'm not good w items,,, :'0
tysm in advance !

2014 uncommons are worth ~4 C$ each.
neckerchiefs are currently (still) in the store and go for 4 C$ each.
the glowy eyes are from 2014 halloween and worth 1-2 commons from 2014 or maybe 1 uncommon at most.

so this trade is fair.

Kia ora, are either of these fair? Thank you!!

If you follow the list, your white dragon is worth about 38-50 '09 rares.
Trade 1 adds up to roughly 58 '09 rares. Trade 2 adds up to roughly 70-89 '09 rares.
Both trades are overpaying, though trade 2 is overpaying more than the 1st.
Any demand is up to you. c:

Okay, thank you! Could I please get a second opinion? c:

as it's clear your expecting to trade for 'retired list worth' i'll second Odd's opinion.
it was a tier 8 on the september list and worth a floppy pink september + their 2 advent (or ~44 '09 rares).
did some quick math and again i'll second Odd's opinion on their trade worths.
Trade to being around 85 rares exactly.
Demand will be up to both of you but I would take the second one as store pets are only going to get more 'expensive' as time goes on ^^

[Ranger of the North]

Kia ora, are either of these fair? Thank you!!

If you follow the list, your white dragon is worth about 38-50 '09 rares.
Trade 1 adds up to roughly 58 '09 rares. Trade 2 adds up to roughly 70-89 '09 rares.
Both trades are overpaying, though trade 2 is overpaying more than the 1st.
Any demand is up to you. c:

as it's clear your expecting to trade for 'retired list worth' i'll second Odd's opinion.
it was a tier 8 on the september list and worth a floppy pink september + their 2 advent (or ~44 '09 rares).
did some quick math and again i'll second Odd's opinion on their trade worths.
Trade to being around 85 rares exactly.
Demand will be up to both of you but I would take the second one as store pets are only going to get more 'expensive' as time goes on ^^

Lol I know just as much about the list now as when it was a thing - nothing XD Is it still fair (or technically overpay I guess, but at the very least fair) without that?

[honeycreeper]

boomp

How much would have do be added to make this fair? Thanks for any help!

[Blue_Aussie]

Help please!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80682870&userid=768234&signature=nQ7ci1kwNp6Tbqfi-Ev8Rw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80683802&userid=768234&signature=Uj_5_SacnMe5plk8x1XQSA

Thanks for any help!

[marshsiren]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80669297&userid=859271&signature=dHkifvpS5QF9zxc3ezFjWw
Hello I was wondering if this is fair, it contains items.
Thank you very much for any help (:

[♥HazelNightmare]

boomp

How much would have do be added to make this fair? Thanks for any help!

Rarity wise it’s fair. The 2015 deer store pet is worth a 2009 rare. The 2017 is a 2010 rare. Demand is up to you and your trading partner and how they value their pet . I know the deer has decent demand. I would ask where they value it at but I wouldn’t over pay and they are pretty easy to come across.

[myworld1000]

I realize both are overpaying but who's overpaying the most?
1
Includes- A '18 store pet, 2 '11 items, 2 '12 items, 7 '13 items, 4 '14 items, and a '15 item
2
Includes- A '12 item, 19 '13 items, and 5 '14 items

[SeriousBusiness]

I realize both are overpaying but who's overpaying the most?
1
Includes- A '18 store pet, 2 '11 items, 2 '12 items, 7 '13 items, 4 '14 items, and a '15 item
2
Includes- A '12 item, 19 '13 items, and 5 '14 items

wrong link! use the one on the bottom c: