The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80683425&userid=790420&signature=uoniqJ7GHsVDNpKD_1jHXQ

is this fair considering the rats are all from 09' ??

Your side = 6 '09 rares
Their side = 3.5 '09 rares + '12 rare
It's unfair to you. How you value your rats "demand wise" is up to you. (:

[riptide17]

Hello! I think there's a thread about "what is my pet worth" but I only log onto this site like twice a year and I'm sure I'm just blind but I cannot for the life of me find it. Can someone tell me what these two pets are each worth in C$? Thank you!

[popping star]

Hello! I think there's a thread about "what is my pet worth" but I only log onto this site like twice a year and I'm sure I'm just blind but I cannot for the life of me find it. Can someone tell me what these two pets are each worth in C$? Thank you!

2017 rares are worth 3-5 C$.
2017 uncommons have no set value. I personally value them at 1.5 C$.

The thread to ask about how much pets are worth in C$ is here. c:

[ANETRA]

Would a TD Sunback for ~10 non worth be fair? (they have the sunback)
Thanks!

[cKy]

in list rarities, would these four pets add up to an '09 special release dog? if npt, what would need to be added on either side?
-pink cake dog (t8 sep list)
-boar pps (t7 advent)
-non- baloon (below gap main)
-fireworks pps (t1 advent)

[popping star]

in list rarities, would these four pets add up to an '09 special release dog? if npt, what would need to be added on either side?
-pink cake dog (t8 sep list)
-boar pps (t7 advent)
-non- baloon (below gap main)
-fireworks pps (t1 advent)

I assume you're referring to the '09 UR dog.
Your side adds up to about the green toxic tier + a low advent.
You'd need to add a little under a balloon dog to your side for it to be fair.
Any demand is up to you. c:

[dogtreat]

Would a TD Sunback for ~10 non worth be fair? (they have the sunback)
Thanks!

would be a biiiiig overpay.
a Sunback was (and still is tbh) only worth 2 nons; TD or not. if someone wanted overpay because of the TD then an extra non would be more than enough. demand is up to both parties but tbh asking for 10 nons would be pretty rough on their part lmao.

[ANETRA]

Would a TD Sunback for ~10 non worth be fair? (they have the sunback)
Thanks!

would be a biiiiig overpay.
a Sunback was (and still is tbh) only worth 2 nons; TD or not. if someone wanted overpay because of the TD then an extra non would be more than enough. demand is up to both parties but tbh asking for 10 nons would be pretty rough on their part lmao.

Ah okay, thank you very much! :) Any other opinions?

Also, would a regular Sunback be fair for a red cerb? (again, their sunback)

[nobxdy]

Would a TD Sunback for ~10 non worth be fair? (they have the sunback)
Thanks!

would be a biiiiig overpay.
a Sunback was (and still is tbh) only worth 2 nons; TD or not. if someone wanted overpay because of the TD then an extra non would be more than enough. demand is up to both parties but tbh asking for 10 nons would be pretty rough on their part lmao.

Ah okay, thank you very much! Any other opinions?

Also, would a regular Sunback be fair for a red cerb? (again, their sunback)

Agreed, I personally wouldn't trade 10 Nons for a Sunback ~ the most I've been seeing it go for lately is around 3-4 Nons? Maybe a little more than that?
I'd say it'd be fair for a Red Cerberus, but it's honestly up to you and your trading partner how you both personally value the Red Cerberus / Sunback. ^^

[Ranger of the North]

Kia ora, are either of these fair? Thank you!!

If you follow the list, your white dragon is worth about 38-50 '09 rares.
Trade 1 adds up to roughly 58 '09 rares. Trade 2 adds up to roughly 70-89 '09 rares.
Both trades are overpaying, though trade 2 is overpaying more than the 1st.
Any demand is up to you. c:

Okay, thank you! Could I please get a second opinion? c: