The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[popping star]

Kia ora, are either of these fair? Thank you!!

If you follow the list, your white dragon is worth about 38-50 '09 rares.
Trade 1 adds up to roughly 58 '09 rares. Trade 2 adds up to roughly 70-89 '09 rares.
Both trades are overpaying, though trade 2 is overpaying more than the 1st.
Any demand is up to you. c:

[ShadowStarFang]

Hello! I was wondering if this person (the ponies) was giving overpay or if it was fair. I am the PPS Ghost Dog.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80674592&userid=410343&signature=UPp37hgdLrDb6294dU0MeQ

Thanks in Advanced!
~ ShadowStarFang

[nobxdy]

Hello! I was wondering if this person (the ponies) was giving overpay or if it was fair. I am the PPS Ghost Dog.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80674592&userid=410343&signature=UPp37hgdLrDb6294dU0MeQ

Thanks in Advanced!
~ ShadowStarFang

They're overpaying, your side is only worth a little more than a 2010 rare (your pps is from 2010). Their side is worth a 2009 rare. (:

[SeriousBusiness]

Is this fair? im not good at trading items as well i dont really know what they're worth most of the time it's just if i want that item i want it lol but i want this to be fair help? thank you in advance ^-^


Here's another trade im not exactly sure about help? thank you!

[nobxdy]

Is this fair? im not good at trading items as well i dont really know what they're worth most of the time it's just if i want that item i want it lol but i want this to be fair help? thank you in advance ^-^


Here's another trade im not exactly sure about help? thank you!

Sorry, I don't know about the item trade, but the second trade is about fair.
2008 very rare = 2 '09 rares + '10 rare, which is exactly what they're offering. Hope this helps. <3

[SeriousBusiness]

Is this fair? im not good at trading items as well i dont really know what they're worth most of the time it's just if i want that item i want it lol but i want this to be fair help? thank you in advance ^-^


Here's another trade im not exactly sure about help? thank you!

Sorry, I don't know about the item trade, but the second trade is about fair.
2008 very rare = 2 '09 rares + '10 rare, which is exactly what they're offering. Hope this helps. <3

thank you so much <3

well on the first one though if we're only trading pets rarity and demand wise would you accept?

[SoulStreamR]

Hi, could I get some help on whether or not these would be a fair trade for my Raven dog?
X1X
X2X
X3X
Thank you in advanced!

[GreenteaLatte]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80674201&userid=224744&signature=Z7sPL7BjJs3yWRapO3_yCA

I value the pps blue malk dragon at around 1.5 nons give or take a few but how much would the top be worth? Do the other punk dogs go as much as the lolita? and how much does the august pps go for these days?

[Soloee]

Is this trade fair?
Thanks for any help!

[dogtreat]

Is this trade fair?
Thanks for any help!

unfair to the other person ^^
their side = currently 5 2011 uncommon + 2012 uncommon
yours = 3 2011 uncommons ^^