The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[skyline]

Thanks for the help... Could you help with these ones too???

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80603662&userid=768234&signature=GQDpDbtpGz-N4pLHmdlfkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80656372&userid=768234&signature=8AP9Vyf90fICi0VfPstq9g

Be very blunt pls, are they fair or not???

The second trade is unfair to you. The top side adds up to about 11.5 '09 rares and a '16 rare.
That's just below a tier 1 September list if you use the list's values. Your pineapple is a main list. c:

Thank u... So the top trade isn't fair either???
Man, I don't get any good trades!!!

the top trade is overpay on their side if you go by the list, but taking in demand, it really depends on how you value your warrior set. despite is being worth about a mid september, i've seen it go for anywhere from a sorbet to a non.

[Blue_Aussie]

Hiii again....

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80671261&userid=768234&signature=B_hJVQf8cHEY2x1vS6Awdw

This one???

[Annabeth00]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80671256&userid=345279&signature=qh2gTKV35moeXfhh7oNYdQ

Is this fair?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80671256&userid=345279&signature=qh2gTKV35moeXfhh7oNYdQ

Is this fair?

Your cat had an extended release until April 2010.
Early 2010 rares are worth 30-35 C$, so the C$ alone is about fair.
Any demand is up to you. c:

[kim seok-jin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80576322&userid=790420&signature=WhiMVfJS-WpU1v-pEDpcnw

Is this fair? the rat is an 09' re release

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80576322&userid=790420&signature=WhiMVfJS-WpU1v-pEDpcnw

Is this fair? the rat is an 09' re release

2009 very rares are worth 2 '09 rares, so it's unfair to you.
Any demand is up for you to decide. c:

[referooni]

Could I have some opinions on this trade please? Thank you c:

[nobxdy]

Could I have some opinions on this trade please? Thank you c:

It's honestly up to you how you value your Raven / their side. I'd see this as around fair considering I only value the Raven around 1-1.5 Nons, and Nons tend to go for around 2 Sorbets or so. However, it's up to you if you want this trade or not / if you're happy with it. (:

[luca_balsa]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80671953&userid=821137&signature=DIIyCS0mB-9fJO38x6Mgzw

[nobxdy]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80671953&userid=821137&signature=DIIyCS0mB-9fJO38x6Mgzw

You're overpaying considering your UR Grapes are OMGSR, and their Raven is only VR.
Demand depends on who you trade / how your trading partner personally values each side.