The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sanitizarium]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80846114&userid=771041&signature=neiCsSlM8me189mgaPF3Sg
need help with this, thank you!

[myth;]

need help with several trades:
#1 trades/viewtrade.php?id=80848948&userid=345279&signature=wrkAmYPl2LnKYe58lqOZeA
rare+items

#2 trades/viewtrade.php?id=80845781&userid=345279&signature=jHp42aEO0ta7OeoATTaXHA
items

#3 trades/viewtrade.php?id=80844543&userid=345279&signature=qtWCVY6dEKag3Qr2zq-MHg
items

#4 trades/viewtrade.php?id=80839243&userid=345279&signature=11Ma1KyuPiyDycrXJZ-cvA
bulk trade

thank you for any help!

Trade one is unfair to them by date, 2016 rare = 2017 uncommon etc.

Trade two if unfair to you, those items are much older than the pets and worth at least an uncommon from the year of their release each.

Trade three is unfair, those cats are worth a 2016 uncommon each.

Trade four, at a quick skim, I'm going to say is unfair to them, though it's close.

[honeycreeper]

hi there, i'm running an auction, and was wondering if any of these bids that I have gotten so far are good!

Bids
- bid 1
- bid 2
- bid 3
- bid 4

thanks for any help!

I'm very bias, but I'm going to say trade one. Items, like store pets, are never re-released and yet rarer with age. The first 6 are from 2009 and, though listed at being worth an 09 rare each, can trade for more to an item collector or someone who is familiar with item value.

The C$ trade is very unfair, a 2009 rare is worth 40C$, so your side is worth 340C$ give or take.
The other two trades are also unfair, though the pet and item trade (the one that includes the spider) may be arguable. I'd get a second opinion to be sure!

thank you so much! can i have another opinion please?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=80846114&userid=771041&signature=neiCsSlM8me189mgaPF3Sg
need help with this, thank you!

Your side adds up to roughly 27-8 '09 rares + a '10 rare, give or take.
(I still valued the '11 store pet at its list value as it still tends to fetch about the same on and off-list.)
If you use the list, the purple bat dog is worth about 42-55 09 rares. It'd be unfair to them.
If you don't use the list, the purple bat dog is worth 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare. It'd be unfair to you.
Any demand is up to you as demand is a personal thing. c:

[Anaraktu]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80848848&userid=794754&signature=g098Md1vG7srrqFOCrq4Tw

[myth;]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80848848&userid=794754&signature=g098Md1vG7srrqFOCrq4Tw

2017 store pets are worth an early 2010 rare each, a 2008 rare is worth an 09 rare and a 2010 rare.
So it's slightly unfair to them. Demand is up to you.

[popping star]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80848848&userid=794754&signature=g098Md1vG7srrqFOCrq4Tw

2017 store pets are worth an early 2010 rare each, a 2008 rare is worth an 09 rare and a 2010 rare.
So it's slightly unfair to them. Demand is up to you.

The dog on the top of the trade had an extended release until August '09. It's worth about a mid-late '09 rare due to that. c:

[Meduz]

Hello I'm wondering about these offers for my seal PPS set.
The ones I'm most interested in are marked so even if I could just get a second opinion on one of those it'd be unbelievably helpful. Or if you could let me know which is better even if you don't know what the PPS set is worth

• one
• two *I like this a lot
• three
• four *really like this one
• five
• six
• seven*interesting

The second trade is pretty good, if you traded those rares for C$ you'd be making a lot of profit.

Yellow toxic trade is decent, both toxic and seal set trade for a sorbet or more, but I'd prefer the seals as they're demand is certain where the toxic's varies.

UR peach is massive overpay, it trades for a non or more, which is better than the seals have traded for that I am aware of.

The Ur cat trade is pretty good, the cat trade for 2 or more nons, the foal one or more, so it's a decent trade.

I'd be torn between the ones mentioned above, so it'd be up to you and would depend on what your goal is.

Thank you, seven has been edited to this.

Any ideas how easy the quantity on the second trade would be to trade?

[luca_balsa]

Is this ok? Tysm
trades/viewtrade.php?id=80849215&userid=821137&signature=-PD38Mjc8bXRSXkQsRfb3w

[Mookna]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80849193&userid=925115&signature=xdIu2nR-QXZIwMClsNNnQA

help please? i think they are over trading?