The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[honeycreeper]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820511&userid=945117&signature=7H7uD22XNu9mmhXBZtH0rQ

this is a small trade, how much would have to be added to be fair? thank you!

[Youngalita]

Can someone help me with this trade? I haven't been on here in a long time and I have know idea how to make this trade fair. I know the items I have are fairly rare (I think)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820660&userid=613515&signature=fP7Bj65Re5KnOy8cZTZHKg

[TheMagicInside56]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820511&userid=945117&signature=7H7uD22XNu9mmhXBZtH0rQ

this is a small trade, how much would have to be added to be fair? thank you!

In my opinion it seems unfair to them. If you wanted it to be balanced, I’d add a 2014 or 2015 common to your side.

[dakotapaws]

disregarding demand, which of these bids seems most
beneficial? I know they're all relatively fair,
but I'm struggling h
bid one + addition
bid two
bid three
bid four
bid five
bid six
bid seven
bid eight
bid nine


you can pm!

and this?
and how fair is this one?

if you were to still refer to the list guide, i'd say bid eight is most beneficial with the advent list pup and the vr plus some!

same with the second trade! the dog they're offering would've been a tier above the grinner you have. it also has considerably better demand then the grinner. the store pet doesn't really fill the gap in my eyes, but if both sides agree on the trade then i think it'd be a satisfactory trade for both sides. uvu

the last trade, i think would be overtrade on your partner's side. this may differ based on user and what they value their pets, but:
i value a '15 very common to a '16 common
a '15 uncommon to a '14 common/2 '14 very commons
a '14 uncommon to a '13 common/2 '13 very commons
so on, so forth.

the two very common '17 dogs can be valued at a '16 common and that'd be equal to a '15 very common.
4 of those very common '15 dogs on their side would be fair for your '14 common.
the '15 uncommon could be a fair swap for your other '15 uncommon

and then the '17 OMG so commons/very commons wouldn't be able to equal up to the last '15 common on their side. ^^"
i hope that makes sense,,?

h thank you for taking the time to go through these omg<3

i really really appreciate the help, and it makes sense cx

[Hellagia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79753884&userid=17787&signature=Immdx2LqbPl88pr9vTftlQ This? Please and thank you, sorry. ^^;

I just realised that's an '08, not an '09 Tess horse. If the items are worth something it would make up for the difference but I'm not sure to what extent. Sorry I couldn't be more helpful x
*Edit, just to clarify, it becomes a bit more unfair with the Tess horse being older.

May I get another opinion? Just in case. ^^;

[powpowx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820816&userid=943796&signature=azmYd3F9GB_o7n7d2rSckA
Is this fair? Thank you so much if you help!! c:

[Kittywittyboo]

I need help with this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820719&userid=825069&signature=alLRD5l9NbxzJkjfW-99WQ

[Kittywittyboo]

Please help me with this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820719&userid=825069&signature=alLRD5l9NbxzJkjfW-99WQ

[세레비]

Please help me with this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820719&userid=825069&signature=alLRD5l9NbxzJkjfW-99WQ

The top is technically overpaying. Your Store Pet is worth a mid '10 Rare, and everything else in your side is worth the 3-months rule. Adding up the VCs and valuing a Common at 2 VCs, your side is worth a mid '10 Rare + 1 '18 Common + '15 Rare + '18 Rare. The Store Pet aside, these pets aren't adding up to the massive time gap between their '11 Rares and those pets.

[Kittywittyboo]

Please help me with this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79820719&userid=825069&signature=alLRD5l9NbxzJkjfW-99WQ

The top is technically overpaying. Your Store Pet is worth a mid '10 Rare, and everything else in your side is worth the 3-months rule. Adding up the VCs and valuing a Common at 2 VCs, your side is worth a mid '10 Rare + 1 '18 Common + '15 Rare + '18 Rare. The Store Pet aside, these pets aren't adding up to the massive time gap between their '11 Rares and those pets.

Are they overpaying?