The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[LionsforScottie]

What should I ask for in return for these minus the mage staff?

The mask is from the medieval event and the sword is from slumber party

[ℋoney]

first one was canceled now, but still looking for a second opinion on this ?

oop and this?

[SnowFallenWebber]

Is this trade fair for the 2008 UR cat?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79749036&userid=882438&signature=M0sL8H7IVKX_Zk337wnH2Q

Edit: got another trades/viewtrade.php?id=79749085&userid=882438&signature=SkSud1RKWa8oD0bGDggPaA

Edit 2: Got another trades/viewtrade.php?id=79752064&userid=882438&signature=MFFxtRfrTkVXNDVk1lLvjQ

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair? They mentioned maybe adding C$. If it needs C$ to balance it, how much would I ask for?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79738576&userid=119355&signature=Bd2eEjhoP5suD1HtyR-kOg

[LionsforScottie]

What should I ask for in return for these minus the mage staff?

The mask is from the medieval event and the sword is from slumber party

[Kazunan]

I’m a bit confused with list worth at the moment so I need help with this, is it fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79745839&userid=907285&signature=nZqBPE3E5hLkkefIvIG5dg
All help is appreciated! <3

[HappyPineapple]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79741807&userid=54445&signature=UUkNicJeI9yBXCJXyH6-yw Would my feb '09 malk re release be about right for the rainbow draft? Or would it be overpay? Thanks in advance <3

[Smittenkitten]

What do you think about this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79752116&userid=211870&signature=9aFcjEY8oFZacFui-Ji3TQ

[Reki.]

Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
Trade 4

Really need help with these, Some look super fair however I want outside opinions on these.
Thank you all for any opinions on these.

For the first trade. Not fair at all, Those are all 2009 very rares for a bunch of recent store pets. And for the one older pet thats on there its the same one you already have but re released. All of them don't even touch the worth of those dogs.

For trade 3, i think its fair. The rare thats being offered is 2 years older then the pets that are being offered for. And the common from 2016 is 'meh' on the trade. But im not very good at staff pets though.

But for a fact i can guarantee that the first trade is super unfair. But for the rest i recommend getting another pair of eyes to look over.

the first one is unfair to them
their side adds up to 7.5 '09 rares and your side adds up to 6 '09 rares

2. '10 vr = 2 '10 rares = '09 rare
the malk dog on their side makes it unfair to them

Thank you, one more opinion please?

[musicgurl333]

Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
Trade 4

Really need help with these, Some look super fair however I want outside opinions on these.
Thank you all for any opinions on these.

Thank you, one more opinion please?

1. Unfair to them. Even if you only value recent store pets at a '10 rare (I personally value them higher) typically 2 '10 rares are considered worth an '09 rare, and 2 '09 rares are considered worth one '09 VR. Their side is worth more than that. Also worth noting that all the dogs were rare before the update, so they're on the lower end of VR.

3. This is a good bit of overpay on their side. Your side is only worth a bit more than a '12 rare.

2. Valuing a VR as 2 rares, this is a bit unfair to them.

4. Typically 2 rares are considered fair for 1 rare that's a year older, so it's fair going by that.