The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[furry!]

x

Can I get some help with this? Thanks!

[Aremisu]

Hi! would you personally accept these trades? thank you! ♥
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79716355&userid=245540&signature=nF2-bp5aKJHpVDqyKjvTHg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703416&userid=245540&signature=SJtOsA_zDIpenuHJzVmTKw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703595&userid=245540&signature=MyYJv9P7YvwVu8jSq-yn7A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79705938&userid=245540&signature=ci4JB3C1ziuuQ9lIaXMN4g (a suggestion, needs to be edited)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79717472&userid=245540&signature=VsEymdvmY5M7LbqO5KEv4g

[StrawBenny]

Any help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79680584&userid=754287&signature=WjW8V54X2DWAu4cYyXVNqw
and
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79680157&userid=754287&signature=OjgMn3Ip_Af-Ph1rcPYM1g
Thanks!

I am not an expert. Consider my opinions loosely.

1st one: I think this trade is fair . Both of the pets involved changed from Very Rares to OMG So Rares during the rarity overhaul early this year. Demand wise I don't know which is more popular. I would personally accept. (Rarity change data taken from here.)

2nd one: Rarity wise their side is worth more by one of the rares. Demand wise I think your side is worth more since some people value dogs more than ponies. If the ponies are wishlist for you then I would think if would be fine to accept. Otherwise the ponies would be harder to trade back out then the pets on your side.

Thanks! Any more opinions ^^?
Also one more hehe
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79680584&userid=754287&signature=WjW8V54X2DWAu4cYyXVNqw

[Vanish]

need help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79724021&userid=932789&signature=4yibplH7t8fEkc1-AE93CA

Unfair to them by quite a bit.
2013 storepet = 2 09 rares (and the llamas are quite liked.)
a singular zodiac can be fairly traded, or at reasonable-maximum, 2 09' rares. (anything more is personal overpay/it varies.)

(( personal trading-value: I value storepets extremely higher than normal pets, since storepets don't get re-released. ))

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79711419&userid=832853&signature=99clnQsokDuAqJBVRAiTeg

Help <3

Unfair to you when you follow the list/demand.
By the list, that cakedog is t8 september list, whilst theirs is only tier 1 on the advent list. (and like someone said below,
it falls under the 3 month rule if I'm correct.)

I'd personally still keep the cakedog because;
- People still use the list and you can get much more for a t8 sept, than a tier1 advent.
- The cakedog is more liked, and less found. (I'd latch onto it.)

Hope I helped.

how about trades/viewtrade.php?id=79723953&userid=804452&signature=JW0BRWx9V7l53PIXAibB7A ?

Unfair to them, a 2014 rare = 2012 uncommon.
( up to you of how you trade. )

[:3c]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79725555&userid=902797&signature=nuP6A_H27anZO0hM_Uy_hg
is this fair?

[세레비]

Is this trade fair? The bandage is originally from Valentines/February 2012, but I'm not entirely certain what it'd be worth. Thank you!

The worth of the bandage is currently being checked on, but I would still love to see some opinions on this!

[TimesTickingByUs]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76278956&userid=761087&signature=yok5cRx8_4X70TW2PSVW_g

[LionsforScottie]

What should I ask in return for these items?

Edit: Thoughts on this one as well?

[Aremisu]

Hi! would you personally accept these trades? thank you! ♥
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79716355&userid=245540&signature=nF2-bp5aKJHpVDqyKjvTHg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703416&userid=245540&signature=SJtOsA_zDIpenuHJzVmTKw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703595&userid=245540&signature=MyYJv9P7YvwVu8jSq-yn7A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79705938&userid=245540&signature=ci4JB3C1ziuuQ9lIaXMN4g (a suggestion, needs to be edited)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79717472&userid=245540&signature=VsEymdvmY5M7LbqO5KEv4g

[musicgurl333]

I'm pretty sure this trade is unfair to them, but would you personally accept it? Please note that I value all store pets as an '09 rare or above. Thanks for any advice!