The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Ashara]

I don’t think this is fair but could someone help me, what would need to be added?

[Aremisu]

Hi! would you personally accept these trades? thank you! ♥
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79701181&userid=245540&signature=sTo9cFel3l6q9mAGVsobXA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79716355&userid=245540&signature=nF2-bp5aKJHpVDqyKjvTHg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703416&userid=245540&signature=SJtOsA_zDIpenuHJzVmTKw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703595&userid=245540&signature=MyYJv9P7YvwVu8jSq-yn7A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79705938&userid=245540&signature=ci4JB3C1ziuuQ9lIaXMN4g (a suggestion, needs to be edited)

I’ll help with ones I can (:
1) I personally wouldn’t, just as I’m not really a fan of the purple bat dog and I think you could get better offers for the pets on your side alone.
4) they’re overpaying by rarity and old list placement. I’d value your side just a little over a sorbet and I’d call it a good deal if you’re looking to trade up since the malk has good demand
5) Id say this is fair, if not slightly unfair to the fox. It’s been OMGSR since release though so has the cat. They’re both ONGSR and could be considered a fair swap.

Thank you!

May I get opinions on the rest / second opinions on the 4th and 5th trade? <3

[MoonDriveZee]

This seems very unfair to me? How to fix it? Thanks

[세레비]

Is this fair? I haven't gotten trades involving items in quite some time, and I'm not exactly certain how to value them or how to go on about trading them. I valued these items at a Very Common/Common of their respective years/months. However, since their side didn't have enough commons from the same year to cover up the Lost City items, I added more items to my end, just as means to ensure that the trade is fair, or that it's at least close to it/they're getting enough for the value of their pets, but despite this, I'm not certain if it's fair.

I would sincerely appreciate any and all help for this! Thank you in advance.

I'm definitely no expert on items, but if you value them at very common/common then I think the trade is fine rarity wise! I personally wouldn't accept though, since I see many players seeking space event/scenery items and they have a bit of demand. Again, I'm no expert and I personally just value these items a bit more, but honestly if you like the pets offered and you don't prioritize items it should be completely ok!

Thank you so much for the response! I really appreciate it.

[Ko6ka]

Help please)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79696618&userid=191752&signature=uhaAZKrhswv_xbV4G_zQIA

[JJdiner]

trade how is this?

[Begs]

is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79717053&userid=858203&signature=wRQkM_Qdsi6nmTLYNt7YRQ

[JJdiner]

This seems very unfair to me? How to fix it? Thanks

this is very unfair to you. they might think it is a list since a few tess horses were but no this one. it is just worth one of your 09 Vrs

[softpaw]

can I get some thoughts on this? would you accept?

[JJdiner]

can I get some thoughts on this? would you accept?

yes their side is huge overpay, even if you only value the 08 as an 09