The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[pikachuiscool]

was this fair? i think they were over even for a store pet

i mean i got the store pet for free so i mean i guess it doest matter too much but i just wanted to know if i could have got more

edit: [url=https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79694300&userid=960605&signature=SyL1yT7ucrc4DI5xUeQ31Q]this too

[Vanish]

-snip

I know their side is worth more, which is why I posted here... I do not want an unfair trade for me OR them. Probably encouraging people to accept an unfair trade isn't the best idea.

I agree, their partner might not know what their pet/s are worth, or is confused.)

But to answer your question:

I got this trade today and I am wondering how I should edit it to make it fair? Please speak in laymans terms as I don't understand all the jargon XD thanks!

totally forgot the link lolol

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79708108&userid=750992&signature=QGBvJu9X9-i1AlPkJxbONg

A 2019 storepet is around a late 2010 rare, so your four 2019 storepets = 2 09 rares (2 2010 = 1 09), so your side is worth one of those 09'VRs ... ( the rest of your pets don't really do anything, so i'd just take them out or leave them in. )

but basically; they're overpaying by a 09' rare & a 09' VR.
- - - - - -

was this fair? i think they were over even for a store pet

i mean i got the store pet for free so i mean i guess it doest matter too much but i just wanted to know if i could have got more

edit: [url=https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79694300&userid=960605&signature=SyL1yT7ucrc4DI5xUeQ31Q]this too

1st. 2015 storepet = mid 2009 rare, i think, their side adds up to a late 09' rare.
the quantity is nice, but I personally wouldn't accept
2nd. Very unfair to you, that butterfly is a re-release from 09'. ( to make this simple, they'd have to remove everything but the 2010 rare dog, and add 3 more 2010 rares.)

[Aremisu]

Hi! would you personally accept these trades? thank you! ♥
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79701181&userid=245540&signature=sTo9cFel3l6q9mAGVsobXA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79702218&userid=245540&signature=4pedxq8SWO_l60oEbwTacw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703416&userid=245540&signature=SJtOsA_zDIpenuHJzVmTKw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79703595&userid=245540&signature=MyYJv9P7YvwVu8jSq-yn7A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79705938&userid=245540&signature=ci4JB3C1ziuuQ9lIaXMN4g (a suggestion, needs to be edited)

[chaotic creativity]

with demand and rarity factored in, what are the chances that the person would accept this trade?

Edit: and this

[DragonReaper13]

-Bid 1
-Bid 2
are these fair at all?

[Vanish]

with demand and rarity factored in, what are the chances that the person would accept this trade?

Edit: and this

1st;
With the shima(some have practically called a "list" pet.) & pps storepet dragon cat, I've seen trades for that go for just one of those pets, (and you'd be lucky to even get that). (I'm not one to inflate, but i'm just making users aware of what they go for because the community likes them so much.) Rarity & pet wise, you're overpaying due to what storepets are normally worth (2014 = early 2009 rare, 2016 = late 2009 rare) but demand wise, ehh, good luck fren! ;w;

2nd; They're overpaying, that dog is a re-release from 09', the oldest item on your side is the dragon wings from 2011(medieval event).

[Alckatraz]

I'm the store pets side
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79712155&userid=932163&signature=0QPsoie1vKbnyDSJbtv0mQ

Help pls

[Vanish]

I'm the store pets side
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79712155&userid=932163&signature=0QPsoie1vKbnyDSJbtv0mQ

Help pls

They're over
Your dogs are storepets(as you know), so, a 2018 storepet = mid 2010 rare, 4 2018 storepets = 2 09' rares.
The fish on their side would cover all your storepets. ^^:

( breakdown more thoroughly:
2018 storepet = 2010 rare
2 2010 rares = 09' rare
4 2010 rares = 2 09' rares, so since a 2018 storepet is worth a 2010 rare, 4 of them makes 2 09' rares.)

[Alckatraz]

I'm the store pets side
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79712155&userid=932163&signature=0QPsoie1vKbnyDSJbtv0mQ

Help pls

They're over
Your dogs are storepets(as you know), so, a 2018 storepet = mid 2010 rare, 4 2018 storepets = 2 09' rares.
The fish on their side would cover all your storepets. ^^:

( breakdown more thoroughly:
2018 storepet = 2010 rare
2 2010 rares = 09' rare
4 2010 rares = 2 09' rares, so since a 2018 storepet is worth a 2010 rare, 4 of them makes 2 09' rares.)

Thank you very much!

[Vanish]

Thank you very much!

AHH WHOOPS, 2 09' rares would equal the fish + another 09' rare or 2 10' rares, super sorry I'm half-awake, fghpid. )