The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Ashara]

I don’t think this is fair but could someone help me, what would need to be added?

[Alckatraz]

Help please, I'm the store pets side
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79712155&userid=932163&signature=0QPsoie1vKbnyDSJbtv0mQ

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair? Would you personally accept? Thank you.

[pikachuiscool]

what can be added, im looking for a fair items trade for this dude so idk if this is fair
this trade

[kitty teeth]

what can be added, im looking for a fair items trade for this dude so idk if this is fair
this trade

I don't think it's fair to you at all due to some of those items being free to get, especially those new St. Patty's items. If I were you, I wouldn't accept it. I suggest getting other opinions though. ♡

[madisong]

what can be added, im looking for a fair items trade for this dude so idk if this is fair
this trade

I don't think it's fair to you at all due to some of those items being free to get, especially those new St. Patty's items. If I were you, I wouldn't accept it. I suggest getting other opinions though. ♡

I agree, they’d need to add a lot. All of those items are fairly recent or worth only a common of their release year.

[Papilio Ulysses]

Is this fair? Please advise.

[madisong]

Is this fair? Please advise.

Veey unfair to you. The rares are a fair swap, a little unfair to them by the three month rule. Though the 2011 uncommon on your side would be overpay for their side entirely. I’d remove it and add a 2017 VC to match their side.

[Papilio Ulysses]

Is this fair? Please advise.

Veey unfair to you. The rares are a fair swap, a little unfair to them by the three month rule. Though the 2011 uncommon on your side would be overpay for their side entirely. I’d remove it and add a 2017 VC to match their side.

Thank you kindly for your help. I'll edit and see if they will work out a better balance with me.

[Keen]

I got this trade today and I am wondering how I should edit it to make it fair? Please speak in laymans terms as I don't understand all the jargon XD thanks!

totally forgot the link lolol

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79708108&userid=750992&signature=QGBvJu9X9-i1AlPkJxbONg

Hello! I personally would take this trade. On your side there's all commons/uncommon and they’re all fairly recent which means they aren’t really worth a whole lot. Your cats may end up very rare or rare, but either way they are still offering 09 very rares for your possible 19 very rare, which is a ten year difference and obviously makes there pets worth more. This is a personal opinion, I’m just sharing what I would do based on how I trade t pets! Hope it helps!

I know their side is worth more, which is why I posted here... I do not want an unfair trade for me OR them. Probably encouraging people to accept an unfair trade isn't the best idea.