The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[LionsforScottie]

Thoughts on this trade? Is it fair to both sides?

[Anaraktu]

is this a fair trade?? please help me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79649014&userid=794754&signature=rzVtEAmbZx2arwwuV3bnwg

[sweetsakura]

is this a fair trade?? please help me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79649014&userid=794754&signature=rzVtEAmbZx2arwwuV3bnwg

i'd say it's fair, the malk is from 2011 and the rudolph lion goes high demand :3

[kaz(:]

Hey, I'm curious if this is fair? I have a liking for my fox, but only enough for small overpay. Thanks in advance!
for me: kaz

[GreenteaLatte]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79656235&userid=224744&signature=iZI69QEJp5cByo3fMS1StA

wondering how this trade is.. still somewhat following the list but I'd like to hear both options using the list and not c:

[Centri]

This+ 500 C$ worth of offsite currency on my side?
I'm not really sure what's standard practice when dealing with C$/currency and a mixture of pets, considering the tier values are quite different as compared to "normal" list trading.

[SoulStreamR]

Hi, could I get some help with these trades?
this and (WARNING: 71 pets 12 items) this
Could I also get some help with this as well?

Thanks again for any help, it’s always appreciated!

[♥HazelNightmare]

Hey, I'm curious if this is fair? I have a liking for my fox, but only enough for small overpay. Thanks in advance!
for me: kaz

Their side is over a lot. Even just a 2009 rare would be over pay enough for it .

[Meduz]

This+ 500 C$ worth of offsite currency on my side?
I'm not really sure what's standard practice when dealing with C$/currency and a mixture of pets, considering the tier values are quite different as compared to "normal" list trading.

I'm not really sure how to give guidance post-list. However, without the list I'd say you are overpaying. You've got two 'list' VRs and a couple of other old VRs. Plus a lot of your items are old and valuable. One of the big issues with the list was that one pet could be worth thousands of another valuable list pet. After the list it seems that people shouldn't be expected to offer this kind of quantity to move up tiers.

The green toxic is only worth 680 C$ and there's significantly more than 180 C$ worth on your side of the trade.

I personally think this trade isn't worth it, but you're welcome to get a second opinion

[Guest]

This+ 500 C$ worth of offsite currency on my side?
I'm not really sure what's standard practice when dealing with C$/currency and a mixture of pets, considering the tier values are quite different as compared to "normal" list trading.

I'm not really sure how to give guidance post-list. However, without the list I'd say you are overpaying. You've got two 'list' VRs and a couple of other old VRs. Plus a lot of your items are old and valuable. One of the big issues with the list was that one pet could be worth thousands of another valuable list pet. After the list it seems that people shouldn't be expected to offer this kind of quantity to move up tiers.

The green toxic is only worth 680 C$ and there's significantly more than 180 C$ worth on your side of the trade.

I personally think this trade isn't worth it, but you're welcome to get a second opinion

I'm not sure of what the offsite currency adds up to, but those are my thougts without it:
If you still use the list it's unfair to the yellow toxic, your side is worth around a balloon dog while their side is worth 2 balloon dogs.
If you don't go by the list it's very unfair to you since you have a few 2008 very rares on your side