The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79472253&userid=722309&signature=h2NoJy5zZsoP1cMHN2jH0Q thank you in advance to anyone who knows, im horrible with lists

The Shima Longtail is only worth the 3 month rule, so they're overpaying massively with the Cake Dog.
Demand is up to you / your trading partner, and how you personally value the pets involved.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79474848&userid=813137&signature=6EZeXY9L-EIh_Fdi2aSY3w

I've never had a trade this large before, I have no idea if this is fair or not for both of us! Please help?

They're overpaying, your pets are too recent to be worth a 2009 rare.

[Alphaess95]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79407774&userid=775822&signature=NcvLkdeR58EIsJniwyUDng

ive been staring at that trade for a few days cant work out if its fair or not? Any advice? thanks

Also this one please? I know that 16 very commons are not hugely expensive but just checking

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79474662&userid=775822&signature=EHbno9kZ0Kt7CigJoSKPAg

Thanks

[raining]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79472253&userid=722309&signature=h2NoJy5zZsoP1cMHN2jH0Q thank you in advance to anyone who knows, im horrible with lists

The Shima Longtail is only worth the 3 month rule, so they're overpaying massively with the Cake Dog.
Demand is up to you / your trading partner, and how you personally value the pets involved.

thanks so much!

[kitty teeth]

Is this fair..? It's for an auction.

[•boo•]

Is this fair?

[nobxdy]

Is this fair..? It's for an auction.

The Shima Longtail is only worth the 3 month rule, so it's unfair to you.
Demand / how you personally value the pets involved is up to you and your trading partner.

[kitty teeth]

Is this fair..? It's for an auction.

The Shima Longtail is only worth the 3 month rule, so it's unfair to you.
Demand / how you personally value the pets involved is up to you and your trading partner.

Okay, thank you! 😊

[~ moth ~]

can i get a second opinion please?

i need help because i'm a noob at trading.
here's the trade link
i'm asking for the staffies but i don't know if i'm under paying, over paying, or if it's fair.

You're slightly overpaying, it is 4 Commons 14 and 1 Uncommon 14 for you're offering pretty much the same + the omgsc rat and the very common pet + items. However, theirs are nice pets and you're offering a lot of rats which people tend to value less than other pets for what they are so I'd say is fair if they undervalue the rats or slight overpay if they don't.

[CelticKitty]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79471017&userid=397255&signature=kECnTCdTg04g58XQMktGGw

May I have another opinion please? I'm a little confused because the null pps is from 2010 I think and my dog is 2009 and camo is extended release 2008.

[size=85]I might be wrong, so don't take my word for it but I'm pretty sure it'd be overpay on your side.
unless you're looking for the Null PPS (which is from 2010) I wouldn't take it.
I think the '09 itself would be enough.
(again, this is just me and how I trade)


Thank you very much.... I really appreciate it!

Edit: may I have just one more?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79471017&userid=397255&signature=kECnTCdTg04g58XQMktGGw

[usedbandaid]

is this a fair trade?