The Rarity Trade Guide

[marmoris]

After we get a good idea on year wise we should start, could someone make a google doc and record pets that would be good options to include on this list that might have been ignored for the Rare's List for one reason or another?

I do not want to run the google docs because I don't want it to seem like I *own* this project.
If we could also have another user record the poll data on a google docs that would be great too!

I can do this! Want me to set that up?

[Clawdina]

You have my full support!
the old list is updated and has quite a few issues that will take too long to resolve and i feel like the community can only anonymously state their opinion so I support something that the community has full control of

[PenguinQueen]

Support 1000% demand should be left out and raiding should be the only thing being disscussed.

Things like URs, store pets and older limited pets are the only things that should be on the list.

Maybe have a store pet list, a UR list, and an older vr/omgsr list? Then have something that compares the values from each list? Maybe

[Rotzalot]

I’d love to set up the document, as I’ve been taking note of pet suggestions as users have posted them.

@ R e d P a n d a
Ooh, wanna do this together? The more, the merrier!

[rentropy]

Support 1000% demand should be left out and raiding should be the only thing being disscussed.

Things like URs, store pets and older limited pets are the only things that should be on the list.

Maybe have a store pet list, a UR list, and an older vr/omgsr list? Then have something that compares the values from each list? Maybe

I like the idea of having seperate lists for both store and ur pets, since their value is so incredibly different.

[nickjr]

I'm not sure I'm comfortable voting in the poll, because if this is going to be a rarity-based list, then I'd much rather have a cutoff for rarity changes rather than pet adoption date, if that makes sense? (and then have notes for pets released after the cutoff that started out as VR since we have no idea where in the VR range they are)

For the pet count project, lil rascal made a list here of all non-List pets that turned VR pretty early, which we are including in our list for the pet counter to count. I feel kinda bad linking it but the pet count project and this rarity-based List idea do overlap a lot and so I think some resources can be shared.

[marmoris]

I’d love to set up the document, as I’ve been taking note of pet suggestions as users have posted them.

@ R e d P a n d a
Ooh, wanna do this together? The more, the merrier!

Sure thing, I totally agree haha. I will PM you a link asap.

[houndoom]

due to some concerns i have heard id like to reiterate that demand is completely user based. and yes it does matter but the reality of the fact is that it is and always will be something subjective and should never be treated as fact. just thought it was worth noting ^^

[emjayy]

After we get a good idea on year wise we should start, could someone make a google doc and record pets that would be good options to include on this list that might have been ignored for the Rare's List for one reason or another?

I do not want to run the google docs because I don't want it to seem like I *own* this project.
If we could also have another user record the poll data on a google docs that would be great too!

I think LufikER has been keeping track of these missed pets for awhile, she's organised too. Would make another good candidate to start the doc as she's already pointed out many of them on the list thread!

[Sinbreaker]

I'm not sure I'm comfortable voting in the poll, because if this is going to be a rarity-based list, then I'd much rather have a cutoff for rarity changes rather than pet adoption date, if that makes sense? (and then have notes for pets released after the cutoff that started out as VR since we have no idea where in the VR range they are)

For the pet count project, lil rascal made a list here of all non-List pets that turned VR pretty early, which we are including in our list for the pet counter to count. I feel kinda bad linking it but the pet count project and this rarity-based List idea do overlap a lot and so I think some resources can be shared.

Of course, mentioned earlier we should consider pets throughout all the years especially if they have been VR for a long time.
But a majority of the pets should come from a certain year date like the rare's list for a good starting point, and then worked on as a community to narrow the trading guide, don't you agree?