The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Phecat]

Phecat wrote:
Would somebody please take a look at this? Any help is greatly appreciated! Thank you so much ahead of time!

Is this fair?

It's fair. Your pets add up to a '09 rare and a '09 uc.

Thank you very much!

[little sunshine]

Would somebody please take a look at this? Any help is greatly appreciated! Thank you so much ahead of time!

Is this fair?

It's fair. Your pets add up to a '09 rare and a '09 uc.

it’s actually unfair to the top user - their side is worth an ‘09 rare + ‘10 uncommon

[JJdiner]

big oof, might i know which is better?
trade 1
trade 2 i really like the TD CEG however i don't quite value this at a 1.3 nons? should i?

[Targaryen]

big oof, might i know which is better?
trade 1
trade 2 i really like the TD CEG however i don't quite value this at a 1.3 nons? should i?

honestly I would, i've always had to pay at least 1.5-2 nons for TD CEGs and they're really annoying to trade for. The UR Lion isn't really on the otherhand.

[emjayy]

big oof, might i know which is better?
trade 1
trade 2 i really like the TD CEG however i don't quite value this at a 1.3 nons? should i?

honestly I would, i've always had to pay at least 1.5-2 nons for TD CEGs and they're really annoying to trade for. The UR Lion isn't really on the otherhand.

I agree, I paid a raven for my TD CEG ^^

[JJdiner]

big oof, might i know which is better?
trade 1
trade 2 i really like the TD CEG however i don't quite value this at a 1.3 nons? should i?

honestly I would, i've always had to pay at least 1.5-2 nons for TD CEGs and they're really annoying to trade for. The UR Lion isn't really on the otherhand.

big oof, might i know which is better?
trade 1
trade 2 i really like the TD CEG however i don't quite value this at a 1.3 nons? should i?

honestly I would, i've always had to pay at least 1.5-2 nons for TD CEGs and they're really annoying to trade for. The UR Lion isn't really on the otherhand.

I agree, I paid a raven for my TD CEG ^^

is it harder to get a TD CEG than a TD BA? (not which is valued more, but harder to get)

[kuzya]

Would somebody please take a look at this? Any help is greatly appreciated! Thank you so much ahead of time!

Is this fair?

It's fair. Your pets add up to a '09 rare and a '09 uc.

it’s actually unfair to the top user - their side is worth an ‘09 rare + ‘10 uncommon

phecat’s side is an ‘09 rare + ‘09 uc worth, how is it unfair to the top user?
they’re offering phecat an ‘09 rare and ‘09 uc. theyre from the very end of the year but pretty much all of phecat’s pets are from the last third of the year as well

[JJdiner]

cutt
phecat’s side is an ‘09 rare + ‘09 uc worth, how is it unfair to the top user?
they’re offering phecat an ‘09 rare and ‘09 uc. theyre from the very end of the year but pretty much all of phecat’s pets are from the last third of the year as well

they have 12 '11s = 6 '10s = 3 '09s
1 rare = 4 ucs


(just me) for myself when i do quantity i do 3:1 instead of 4:1 so even if i did that it would be
3(4) ucs = 4 '11 rares = 2 '10 rares = 1 09 and not equate the 09 rare plus 09

[spencer]

cutt
phecat’s side is an ‘09 rare + ‘09 uc worth, how is it unfair to the top user?
they’re offering phecat an ‘09 rare and ‘09 uc. theyre from the very end of the year but pretty much all of phecat’s pets are from the last third of the year as well

they have 12 '11s = 6 '10s = 3 '09s
1 rare = 4 ucs

That makes sense actually, I thought two ucs = 1 rare.
Thanks for clearing it up lmao

[Targaryen]

@jjd
the TD CEG is definitely harder to trade for and find to begin with. Remember that Black Advents aren't even rarer than their other Christmas dog advents. They at most go for a 1:1 non swap. ^^