The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ironic Equation]

Should I do this? I'm rather tempted by that quantity <3

Thank you so much! I just don't know whether to accept them based on demand etc. What would you do?

.

[Byuller]

Oh gosh bulk warning, 142 pets 18 items
Consists of:
-Non
-A few advent of different values
-Dark leopard
-tons of rares/store pets of different years
Is the quantity worth it?

Just the Non and the Dark Leopard are enough to pay for it. Here it really depends on how much both sides value the Cerb on. Technically it is worth 2 Mid Advents but people value it "usually" at a Non-worth, some may worth it more but they overprice it quite a bit like if it was worth a Moonswirl (it's sickening).

They're overpaying in my eyes, but I would definitely ask for a second opinion since I value the Cerb on a Non, others may not.

[TheVixen&TheRaven]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79200660&userid=669103&signature=0In65QqRlvcfcWn1FrFk0w
I really like this bid for my spotted tribal, but I have no idea about how rarity and demand works. Would like to get an opinion on if this is fair or not. Thanks

[rosé]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79206706&userid=952073&signature=nCcU5ctthMhmGXOk3qJqpw

is this fair? any help would be appreciated! c:

[Sali]

Can I get some help with these list pet trades? c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79137520&userid=273533&signature=ZnDPqW1mIb814xKNqENS2Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79141832&userid=273533&signature=lbMT0Tvur8-uDfrigvn0ZA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79145396&userid=273533&signature=ah_eSjDcjlzippDcaQtTxQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79205473&userid=273533&signature=PjzhCN3XcubmTeSauPELyA

[frogicat]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79132325&userid=942594&signature=uJhkx4R0ds6AMO73WUV8lg
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208427&userid=942594&signature=M7-jNP8OH6_4jfQ2O0IXVg
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208415&userid=942594&signature=3NJwgLHXXQ0XZRBUjKiaxw
Are these fair? Thank you for any help, it means a lot!

[Sweetfrog]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208630&userid=633510&signature=pnLI7rabVNbW4Yi4k5Wo1w

[Ironic Equation]

Should I do this? I'm rather tempted by that quantity <3

Thank you so much! I just don't know whether to accept them based on demand etc. What would you do?

.

[Redpanda]

Oh gosh bulk warning, 142 pets 18 items
Consists of:
-Non
-A few advent of different values
-Dark leopard
-tons of rares/store pets of different years
Is the quantity worth it?

Just the Non and the Dark Leopard are enough to pay for it. Here it really depends on how much both sides value the Cerb on. Technically it is worth 2 Mid Advents but people value it "usually" at a Non-worth, some may worth it more but they overprice it quite a bit like if it was worth a Moonswirl (it's sickening).

They're overpaying in my eyes, but I would definitely ask for a second opinion since I value the Cerb on a Non, others may not.

Thank you, may i get a second opinion?

[Byuller]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79132325&userid=942594&signature=uJhkx4R0ds6AMO73WUV8lg
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208427&userid=942594&signature=M7-jNP8OH6_4jfQ2O0IXVg
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=79208415&userid=942594&signature=3NJwgLHXXQ0XZRBUjKiaxw
Are these fair? Thank you for any help, it means a lot!

1. They're slightly overpaying there.
2. I can't really value the items since I don't know their value but new Store Pets are not worth that many 09 Rares, a 09 Rare is worth perhaps 4-5 New Store Pets so as I see it they're overpaying but as I said, I don't know on what are the items value, ask for a second opinion.
3. It's a fair trade if not overpay for you since it may be a VR 09 Cat but it is not a list pet and it's only real value is that it's a Warrior Cat.