The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[syriasirlay]

Even with all my time on this site, I'm still garbage with the rarity knowledge. Did a bit of research myself, but I'd like some other opinions.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79028096&userid=23279&signature=q69Y7NOFzvJidvJKc3z-og

[Animall]

Even with all my time on this site, I'm still garbage with the rarity knowledge. Did a bit of research myself, but I'd like some other opinions.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79028096&userid=23279&signature=q69Y7NOFzvJidvJKc3z-og

Their bun is from 2010 and worth 2 2010 rares or 1 2009 rare. Extremely unfair to you.

[saucycorndog]

Im not really familiar with item worths so any help is greatly appreciated!
Tysm is advance <33

[LuckyHeart]

I value the bengal at 1.5 nons, but I also realize that the UR Bwolf is huge overpay rarity-wise. But what is it going for currently? Would I be better off keeping the bengal until I know where it (and its demand) end up when the list is restructured?

[Puptarts]

Even with all my time on this site, I'm still garbage with the rarity knowledge. Did a bit of research myself, but I'd like some other opinions.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79028096&userid=23279&signature=q69Y7NOFzvJidvJKc3z-og

Valuing 2 09 rares at a 09 vr and 2 '10 rares at a 09 rare,
your side adds up to 3 09 rares + a 10 rare and i dont think the bunny is on the list so its unfair to you

[syriasirlay]

Even with all my time on this site, I'm still garbage with the rarity knowledge. Did a bit of research myself, but I'd like some other opinions.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79028096&userid=23279&signature=q69Y7NOFzvJidvJKc3z-og

Their bun is from 2010 and worth 2 2010 rares or 1 2009 rare. Extremely unfair to you.

Valuing 2 09 rares at a 09 vr and 2 '10 rares at a 09 rare,
your side adds up to 3 09 rares + a 10 rare and i dont think the bunny is on the list so its unfair to you

Aight, that's what I figured. Thanks.

[GhostPants]

Honestly i have no idea, any opinions?
I also have this one, so any help on any is appreciated! <3
aaand another one!
another one! <3
aaaAA another.. ;w;
a-another one... im sorry

- Gasoline

Okay well, a lot of this is based on how people individually value the pets, but I'll try and help <3
1. I'd value both the zebra and the bwolf at about 1.5 to maybe 2 nons with 'demand', so this one's totally up to you. I'd say the bwolf is slightly more liked, but the difference is marginal.
2. Definitely very very unfair to you.
3. My trade so I won't say anything.
4. I certainly wouldn't. Not only does the rarity update reveal that the pickle is probably less rare than the bengal, but it has much worse demand. I tend to see the bengal get about 4 sorbets worth and the pickle get about two.
5. This one's up to you again. I see the cinnabun going for the same/slightly more than the bengal generally, but probably not a sorbet more. List wise the cinnabun is worth a non + a sorbet currently, meaning they're valuing the bengal at a non. I feel like the bengal could do better. I'd say more likely than not they'll end up on the same tier or the cinnabun being one above when the dust settles with the list.
6. I probably wouldn't. Yes people are constantly saying the bwolf is worth a non with 'demand' but I'd say you could get more if you found the right person.

Cool beans!
Im just going to get a 3rd opinion on a few of the other trades tho, just to be 100% ^^

[aloe.]

Is this fair? I feel like it is the three month rule, but I just wanna check.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79065967&userid=941763&signature=h608J8z9een4KjqNBfXBiA

[Xann]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79066022&userid=958106&signature=ExoE236BwGvqTfElCneD2w

Is this fair?

[Puptarts]

Is this fair? I feel like it is the three month rule, but I just wanna check.

No link?
-
how was this? they told me grinners have no demand but im pretty sure thats not true?