The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[strawberrywolf28]

Is this fair? Thanks if you do help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054865&userid=640920&signature=ctiaiU_Z3pixAqhPmdAJCQ

[Kazin]

How fair is this trade? I am not sure what items are worth..
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054920&userid=328540&signature=mz461H_T_GXLNe7S22dvFg

Very unfair to you! The hearts are an item from Valentines 2009 and are worth around a mid '09 rare.

[COOKIESANDMILK]

Thank you Kazin!!

[WindowsOS]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054891&userid=930590&signature=3yq2NOOZbldvAc82Hb4ooQ

Is this fair :0

[gowonnie]

NEED URGENT HELP
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79040566&userid=939598&signature=dUXLEvlK4tpdTk85RH_O0A

[opalineteardrops]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054854&userid=350878&signature=gxuju3sQJV14NrwL0l1Zgw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054872&userid=350878&signature=-h4Q0PHi0vhlsYuLVEyCew

what can i do to these two ? : )

1 - Unfair to you. Remove all but the '13 rare
2 - roughly fair

How fair is this trade? I am not sure what items are worth..
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054920&userid=328540&signature=mz461H_T_GXLNe7S22dvFg

Unfair to you - those hearts I THINK were from Valentines day 2010. Dont quote me on that one - but I know they were released before my time (2012) and therefore, the trade is unfair to you.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054891&userid=930590&signature=3yq2NOOZbldvAc82Hb4ooQ

Is this fair :0

Unfair to you

Is this fair? Thanks if you do help :)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054865&userid=640920&signature=ctiaiU_Z3pixAqhPmdAJCQ

Unfair to them

NEED URGENT HELP
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79040566&userid=939598&signature=dUXLEvlK4tpdTk85RH_O0A

Please be patient - there isn't always people around on the thread able to help out
Unfair to you

yall i'm stumped

what have true date jokers been going for lately? aa huge thanks for any opinions

Truedates are worth no more/less than their re-release counterparts.
If you value the Joker at a Sorb, it was unfair to you
If you value the Joker at a Non, it was unfair to them

[GhostPants]

how is this bid for my auction [X]?
- Gasoline

[kkspecial4]

NEED URGENT HELP
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79040566&userid=939598&signature=dUXLEvlK4tpdTk85RH_O0A

The Joker Bunny is listed at 590 C$
An Early 2009 Rare/Very Rare is listed at 45-50 C$

Before the rarity update I would have said that this was fair or roughly fair - however since the change to the rarity system and the change in the rarity of the Joker Bunny it is noted to be moved up on the list and is no longer worth it's current list value

Personally I would not trade anything set to be moved since the change until more about it's new placement is known - but that is ultimately up to you.

For more information on what is set to be moved and such I believe there was a discussion on the Rares List Thread

[Xeroxoe]

Second opinion? xxx
And
xxx
What would need to be added, if anything, to either?
Thank you for your time!

[Kazin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054854&userid=350878&signature=gxuju3sQJV14NrwL0l1Zgw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79054872&userid=350878&signature=-h4Q0PHi0vhlsYuLVEyCew

what can i do to these two ? : )

1 - Unfair to you. Remove all but the '13 rare
2 - roughly fair

I disagree with the second trade.
Valuing a 2011 rare at two 2012 rares = 4 '13 rares and so on, it should in theory be worth at least 14 2018 rares. However, not many pay that much quantity, but this trade is unfair to the bottom. I value the bunny side at a '14-'15 rare max. However, quantity trades usually go for underpay and not the older pets true worth.