The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ingenuity,]

oh, my...
I would like some help. I have no idea what's worth what.
edit: there's another. um, any suggestions/opinions? what would y'all do? thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78853672&userid=761992&signature=KkgHwyfaNK5rXLh-ttl_BA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78853685&userid=761992&signature=yNbuczvPPtH5p7N-hGBOMg

Zebras have horrible demand, so you are overpaying in the second one.

1. unfair to you, phoenix is worth 1 non + 1 sorbet and they only have 1 non on their side
2. list wise unfair to them, mountain zebra is worth 3 nons and your side adds up to around 1 non + ~ur flower, personally i wouldn't do it because i don't value zebras that high

thank you!

[CorgiNerd]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78853805&userid=932541&signature=1mEFwLx5_kscfYCxZ8jzYw
Is this fair?

[Targaryen]

opinions?
I know the peach doesn't have the best demand so I'm hesitant to take it.

no 'rarity' advice please

[justina valentine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78853805&userid=932541&signature=1mEFwLx5_kscfYCxZ8jzYw
Is this fair?

Unfair to them just with the dog their pet is on the September list and worth more than your two advents + 2 rares.

opinions?
I know the peach doesn't have the best demand so I'm hesitant to take it.

no 'rarity' advice please

The jeweled liontail goes for 1-2 nons I value the peach at 2ish nons. I would decline and wait for another offer you could probably get more/quantity for the liontail since they are quiet popular at the moment. But it really depends what your looking for I guess, if you want the peach go for it if your looking to trade the peach I'd stick with the liontail as it will be easier to trade off.

Edit: I have seen that the peach can get a non threw looking around a bid just depends again what you want <3

[Puptarts]

opinions?
I know the peach doesn't have the best demand so I'm hesitant to take it.

no 'rarity' advice please

the peach tends to get around a non and the liontail a sorbet
the peach could be placed at or even above the nons too so even with any bad demand the peach has i would take it

[fιяєfℓу]

Help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78840087&userid=865662&signature=usscc26dAmUbtZ9wsnaGJw

[mental-mayhem]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78852496&userid=711247&signature=moWCQBeqqP203mpf4NCCxg
Opinions?
The item is from the 09’ valentines event, and the dog is from January 09’.

[abbie.]

x
Opinions?
Would you personally take this, if no/yes, why?

x
Could I get opinions on this too?
Would you personally take it? If yes/no, why?

x
Opinions?
Would you personally take it? If yes/no, why?

[Puptarts]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78852496&userid=711247&signature=moWCQBeqqP203mpf4NCCxg
Opinions?
The item is from the 09’ valentines event, and the dog is from January 09’.

just the '09 rare + '09 item (worth a c/uc from its release year) would be enough, you are overpaying

[mental-mayhem]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78852496&userid=711247&signature=moWCQBeqqP203mpf4NCCxg
Opinions?
The item is from the 09’ valentines event, and the dog is from January 09’.

just the '09 rare + '09 item (worth a c/uc from its release year) would be enough, you are overpaying

Thank you for the input. c:
Could I have a second opinion, please?