The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Puptarts]

Yellow toxin + ______ equals Gearback Tribal?

yellow toxic side i believe would have to add about a nonballoon tier to make this fair-please get a second opinion on this though ^^

[Swifty98]

Hello! Does anyone know if this trade is fair? I've been asking consistently for 5 days and haven't had a response yet - I'd really appreciate some help! I'm not very good with knowing what's fair when it comes to items. Thanks in advance!

unfair to them, the items are worth a 2014 common/uncommon each and the cookies a 2013 c/uc each and i believe your side adds up to a '14 common + '15 common

Thank you so much! For future reference, how do you know what items are generally worth? Are they worth a common/uncommon pet from the same year? (Although I recognize that different people will value items differently!)

[Mishi23]

Is this trade fair? Thank you!

Can someone help me with this? Thank you ♥

[Puptarts]

Hello! Does anyone know if this trade is fair? I've been asking consistently for 5 days and haven't had a response yet - I'd really appreciate some help! I'm not very good with knowing what's fair when it comes to items. Thanks in advance!

unfair to them, the items are worth a 2014 common/uncommon each and the cookies a 2013 c/uc each and i believe your side adds up to a '14 common + '15 common

Thank you so much! For future reference, how do you know what items are generally worth? Are they worth a common/uncommon pet from the same year? (Although I recognize that different people will value items differently!)

yes, most items are worth a common/uc from their release year besides items on this list and some off it

this?

unfair to them, your store pet is only worth 45-50 c$ (not including any demand)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78817392&userid=634965&signature=JlWsn_0jl5gzeDA9RKetaw

Any help is appreciated ahh!

unfair to them, your side is worth 2 09 rares and their side is worth 3

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78705303&userid=857986&signature=oMvZyabN661kcuiK86FTFQ
Fair?

[GhostPants]

Is a yellow toxic fair for a marionette dog ^^?
I know the demand is very high for those little things ^^;
New trade! How is it ^^? [ 2nd Opinion ]
I heard the WWA Goes for semi underpay, but im not sure?
Another trade! How is this?
Oh and, low sept + ?? = Patchwork
- Gasoline

[Puptarts]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78705303&userid=857986&signature=oMvZyabN661kcuiK86FTFQ
Fair?

unfair to you, their pet is just an advent list while yours is definitely going to be on the main list. + scarf pps/pink striped september (not including any demand)

GWJ + Nontag = Coontail?

[~Loki~]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78705303&userid=857986&signature=oMvZyabN661kcuiK86FTFQ
Fair?

unfair to you, their pet is just an advent list while yours is definitely going to be on the main list. + scarf pps/pink striped september (not including any demand)

Please don’t give uneducated advice. The Raven has gone for above gap mainlists for years due its high demand.

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair? Thank you.

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78705303&userid=857986&signature=oMvZyabN661kcuiK86FTFQ
Fair?

Thank you:) but what about demand wise?