The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Darthcassandra]

Would a noncoon be worth every non-list store pet on the site? If not, what would need to be added?

That is 193 pets, all non-lists. A complete, non-list store pet collection.

[GhostPants]

Is a yellow toxic fair for a marionette dog ^^?
I know the demand is very high for those little things ^^;
New trade! How is it ^^?
Another trade! How is this?
Oh and, low sept + ?? = Patchwork
- Gasoline

[St. Seraphimz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78824528&userid=764221&signature=kqIaAsmI9wGj-u-_-J07Ig

^^

[vampz]

which of these 3 trades would be the best for my ur cinnabon?

1
2
3
how do they look, or which would be the best of the three?
thank you for any help.

I’m pretty sure the best out of the best would be the last trade offer... Although it may be a bit unfair on their side, but I’m not totally sure... That’s all!

thanks a ton!
any chance i can get a second opinion, since i'm not 100% on the zebra's demand?

[Puptarts]

Is a yellow toxic fair for a marionette dog ^^?
I know the demand is very high for those little things ^^;
New trade! How is it ^^?
Oh and, low sept + ?? = Patchwork
- Gasoline

the wing wood angel is worth 21 mid advents, they are asking for 10-12 so unfair to them

which of these 3 trades would be the best for my ur cinnabon?

1
2
3
how do they look, or which would be the best of the three?
thank you for any help.

I’m pretty sure the best out of the best would be the last trade offer... Although it may be a bit unfair on their side, but I’m not totally sure... That’s all!

thanks a ton!
any chance i can get a second opinion, since i'm not 100% on the zebra's demand?

1. the coontail is worth 2 nons, there is discussion about moving it down the list though so i would turn down this trade
2. they're offering a non + 2 sorbets + a red rose, i believe they're overpaying
3. their side is 3 nons+ a blue toxic, not sure about demand though.

Nontag + White July = Coontail?

[Sorbo]

Does the flower pot have low demand? Is trading my GWJ good for it? I just want it so I can try to trade it up or for the UR hollydog

[Lunarsnow]

Can I get opinions on these three trades please? I'm mostly concerned with trade one if no one wants to talk about all three.

Trade one: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78761708&userid=626333&signature=Grkw3bTk7i7nVMN-mODz-Q

Trade two: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78790223&userid=626333&signature=cH2UXaAN646toOrsxxoY8A

Trade three: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78825181&userid=626333&signature=vjN37IaLAcC8nzopQkUkmg

[Swifty98]

Hello! Does anyone know if this trade is fair? I've been asking consistently for 5 days and haven't had a response yet - I'd really appreciate some help! I'm not very good with knowing what's fair when it comes to items. Thanks in advance!

[Sorbo]

Does the flower pot have low demand? Is trading my GWJ good for it? I just want it so I can try to trade it up or for the UR hollydog

Please I really need help from someone.

[Puptarts]

Hello! Does anyone know if this trade is fair? I've been asking consistently for 5 days and haven't had a response yet - I'd really appreciate some help! I'm not very good with knowing what's fair when it comes to items. Thanks in advance!

unfair to them, the items are worth a 2014 common/uncommon each and the cookies a 2013 c/uc each and i believe your side adds up to a '14 common + '15 common

Nontag + GWJ = coontail?